Performance Reviews

Reviews of operatic, vocal, and classical performances at the Metropolitan Opera, Carnegie Hall, all across America, and around the world.

La voix surhumaine La voix surhumaine

Barbara Hannigan mesmerizes as both a brilliant vocalist and a proficient opera conductor in a double bill of Strauss and La voix humaine with the New York Philharmonic.

The night is dark and full of terrors The night is dark and full of terrors

Opera Baltimore concludes its season with a piercing semi-staged production of Pelléas et Mélisande.

Hustle your bustle Hustle your bustle

Opera San José‘s La Traviata has all the buzz and energy of a world premiere.

Big man in town Big man in town

A strong revival of Falstaff at the Los Angeles Opera proves a fitting farewell vehicle for Music Director James Conlon.

Now sleeps the crimson petal Now sleeps the crimson petal

Gregory Spears’s Sleepers Awake mystifies and delights at Opera Philadelphia.

Come and Gandhi Come and Gandhi

Led by a mesmerizing Anthony Roth Costanzo, Satyagraha at the Paris Opera dispenses with historical particularities for something for more elusive.

Kuda, woulda, shoulda Kuda, woulda, shoulda

A strong revival of Eugene Onegin at the Metropolitan Opera and a recital by Benjamin Bernheim offered the chance to hear “Kuda, kuda” twice in two days.

Trouble in paradise Trouble in paradise
The New York Gilbert and Sullivan Players‘s vivacious music making compensates for uninspired storytelling in their staging of Utopia, Limited.
Dodging a bullet Dodging a bullet

Dull conducting makes Der Freischütz miss its mark at Carnegie Hall.

Northern lights Northern lights

SoCal goes Scandi in two recent concerts, with one featuring an appearance by Lise Davidsen.

Bach to Bach Bach to Bach

An invigorating double bill at the San Francisco Symphony challenges how Bach “should” be performed.

That time of evening That time of evening

Golda Schultz soldiers through illness at the New York Philharmonic.

Heaven, here within my heart Heaven, here within my heart

The Chicago Symphony Orchestra explores love and death in an intense, intelligent program featuring soprano Corinne Winters.

Rose to the occasion Rose to the occasion

The embattled Andris Nelsons and the Boston Symphony Orchestra bring Adams and Dvorák to Carnegie Hall.

Seder play Seder play

A new DVD recording of La Juive boasts considerable musical strengths in spite of a frustrating production.

Where imitation ends Where imitation ends
Daring reimaginings of Cocteau and Wilde take the stage at the Los Angeles Philharmonic.
Darkling I listen Darkling I listen

Golda Schultz casts darkness in an alluring light in an intimate recital at the New Orleans Opera Festival.

A specter, haunting A specter, haunting

Kaija Saariaho’s spectral, shattering Innocence makes its Metropolitan Opera debut.

Festspiel for the consecration of the French Quarter Festspiel for the consecration of the French Quarter

The inaugural New Orleans Opera Festival goes big across the Big Easy.

Cavalcade of stars Cavalcade of stars

Back-to-back casts in the Metropolitan Opera’s revivals of Madama Butterfly and La traviata offer ample opportunity for soprano-gazing.

Asp and you shall receive Asp and you shall receive

A first-time operagoer is lured to Thaïs at Opera Idaho by the promise of a new experience… and Neil, the Burmese python

Youth has no age Youth has no age

Led by Yannick Nézet-Séguin and Yoann Combémorel, the Curtis Symphony Orchestra proves themselves the equal of any major American orchestra in a program of Mahler, Wagner, and Dawson.

Anime sante degli avi Anime sante degli avi

Madama Butterfly confronts anime, virtual reality, and weeaboos in Matthew Ozawa‘s bold production at the Lyric Opera of Chicago.

Hit me with your best Shoshty Hit me with your best Shoshty

Barrie Kosky’s zany production of The Nose time-steps back onto the Komische Oper Berlin stage.