Performance Reviews

Reviews of operatic, vocal, and classical performances at the Metropolitan Opera, Carnegie Hall, all across America, and around the world.

Doublet trouble Doublet trouble

A messy new I puritani at the Met is a historic and historical disappointment.

The offal truth The offal truth

“Call me traditional, but I want to see a silver platter!”

Car Park Casta Diva Car Park Casta Diva

Fine music-making meets a clunker of a production in La Monnaie‘s revival of Norma

O stars of wonder, stars of night O stars of wonder, stars of night

A starry (and potentially annual) Christmas gala lights up Carnegie Hall.

Reduce, reuse, recycle Reduce, reuse, recycle

Global warming meets the cool factor in The Seasons.

Life in the Faust lane Life in the Faust lane

Théâtre de l’Athénée Louis-Jouvet mounts a raucous production of Hervé’s Le petit Faust. 

Better the devil you know Better the devil you know

America’s own Faust gets a compelling operatic treatment, courtesy of DC’s IN Series

Mein Lieder Schwan Mein Lieder Schwan

Matthew Polenzani charms the pants off of Philadelphia.

Capital punishment Capital punishment

A patchy production and musical performance can’t dull the edge of Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny at the Komische Oper Berlin

Saint-Ex marks the spot Saint-Ex marks the spot

Washington National Opera’s holiday presentation of The Little Prince, based on the classic French novella by Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, showcased the company’s Cafritz Young Artists

I listen to the wind of my soul I listen to the wind of my soul

Washington Concert Opera began its 39th season last month with Christoph Willibald Gluck’s late masterpiece Iphigénie en Tauride.

When Pushkin comes to shove When Pushkin comes to shove

An incoherent production of Ruslan and Lyudmila at the Hamburg State Opera may dispense with the fantastical, but Glinka‘s magic remains.

Old friends, new friends Old friends, new friends

Les Arts Florissants present two ravishing programs in Brooklyn and Manhattan. 

Now I’m an old believer Now I’m an old believer

Big voices overwhelm Claus Guth‘s toothless staging of Khovanshchina at the Berlin Staatsoper.

Sublime loneliness Sublime loneliness

Across three evenings at the 92nd Street Y, Konstantin Krimmel and Ammiel Bushakevitz traversed all of Schubert‘s major song cycles with stark intensity.

Follow your bliss Follow your bliss

In recital for the Los Angeles Opera, tenor Ben Bliss makes the case for the next stage of his career.

<i>Carmen</i>, again? <i>Carmen</i>, again?

Gulfshore Opera’s vigorous production of Carmen answers a familiar question.

All the fine young cannibals All the fine young cannibals

Offenbach‘s Robinson Crusoé is salvaged from obscurity. 

Mezzo in the dark Mezzo in the dark

It is a physical pleasure to hear Kate Lindsey at close quarters.

Scenes from a revolution Scenes from a revolution

This isn’t an opera that touches on queer themes; it’s a bundle of queer themes tied up in an opera.”

Form over function Form over function

A consideration of Anika Kildegaard’s extraordinary recital in Philadelphia—and the oddity of recitals themselves. 

Paris is always a good idea Paris is always a good idea

Though perhaps showing its age, a storied production of La bohème nonetheless makes a welcome return to the Los Angeles Opera

Get in the zone Get in the zone

Tamara Wilson and Stanislas de Barbeyrac are the standouts in Calixto Bieito’s underwhelming Die Walküre in Paris

Shades of gray Shades of gray

MasterVoices presents a strongly-cast Sweet Smell of Success—but the merits of this noir musical are hardly black or white.