Performance Reviews

Reviews of operatic, vocal, and classical performances at the Metropolitan Opera, Carnegie Hall, all across America, and around the world.

Diva down Diva down

An excellent Věc Makropulos at Opéra de Lille makes the case for the vitality and necessity of France’s regional companies.

Di qualità, di qualità! Di qualità, di qualità!

San Diego Opera presents a strongly directed and cast revival of Il barbiere di Siviglia. 

Was keinem in Worten ich künde Was keinem in Worten ich künde

In Modena, Teodor Currentzis‘s Ring ohne Worte foregoes words but not gimmickry.

Mother is mothering Mother is mothering

Marina Rebeka comes tantalizingly close to triumph in Cherubini’s Médée at Théâtre des Champs Elysées.

Baroque in the Bay Area Baroque in the Bay Area

Under the baton of Nicholas McGegan, Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra & Chorale proves they have a magic touch in a program of Rameau and Handel.

A shtetl aesthetic A shtetl aesthetic

Austin Opera’s moving production of Fiddler on the Roof grounds itself in lived tradition, to great effect.

Americana, reconsidered Americana, reconsidered

Davóne Tines leads a thought-provoking program in San Francisco reconsidering patriotism, dissent, and spirituality as the United States faces down its quarter millennium crisis.

Life of the Mardi Life of the Mardi

La Monnaie’s flamboyantly busy new production of Benvenuto Cellini reads more burlesque than Berlioz.

Gender? I hardly know her! Gender? I hardly know her!

Christof Loy’s production of Pablo Luna’s gender-bending Orientalist farce Benamor proves to be irresistible.

Beam me up, Selim Beam me up, Selim

Die Entführung aus dem Serail boldly goes where no opera has gone before at Pacific Opera Project. 

Uncovered gems Uncovered gems

Despite some complications, the Deutsche Oper exhumes buried treasure in Franz Schreker’s Der Schatzgräber. 

Extravaganza of ideas Extravaganza of ideas

Iván Fischer‘s Mahler 3 with the Budapest Festival Orchestra at Carnegie Hall is memorable but crude, sometimes exhilarating and often tedious.

No shrinking Violanta No shrinking Violanta

A chic production of Violanta at the Deutshce Oper Berlin continues the Korngold craze on the other side of the Atlantic.

The crowd-pleaser comes around The crowd-pleaser comes around

Juan Diego Flórez‘s charm and artistic sensibility remain as vibrant as ever, as seen at a recent Carnegie Hall recital.

One is silver, the other is Golda One is silver, the other is Golda
In an all-Mozart program with the San Francisco Symphony, Golda Schultz shows that her soubrette days are behind her.
The arc of life The arc of life

The dazzling and deeply moving Complications in Sue bodes well for Anthony Roth Costanzo‘s stewardship of Opera Philadelphia.

I want you to enter the holy of holies I want you to enter the holy of holies

Das Wunder der Heliane fuses sex with the sacred at a simmering performance at the Opéra National du Rhin.

More than a material girl More than a material girl

The vivacious MANON! at Heartbeat Opera makes a strong case for the return of opera in translation.

Past is prologue Past is prologue

Simon Boccanegra has never felt as foreboding or prophetic as it did at a recent performance at La Fenice.

A lady of coarse and vulgar inclinations A lady of coarse and vulgar inclinations

A stark, sweltering performance of Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk shocks the Komische Oper Berlin.

Nature boy Nature boy

With Siegfried, the directorial vision of the Paris Opera‘s Ring cycle finally takes root.

A ruckus in Kaunas A ruckus in Kaunas

Ponchielli goes east with mixed results in I Lituani.

Methinks the lady doth protestant too much Methinks the lady doth protestant too much

Old pros Gregory Kunde and Pier Luigi Pizzi anchor a new staging of Stiffelio co-produced by three theaters in Emilia-Romagna.

The snows that lie on the mountains of Judaea The snows that lie on the mountains of Judaea

Salome sweeps in like a storm at the Lyric Opera of Chicago.