Sigh! I think most of you realized I would pick this one. Got that “Donizetti and Bellini Heroines” from the Record Club of America when I was in my teens and playing it to death.

This to me is everything that makes Donizetti the great dramatist of the bel canto era.

The brave and beautiful Maartje Offers – best known from the potted Ring – lends her charismatic voice to Donizetti here.

Maybe this is an obvious choice, but this is the sort of performance that every opera queen dreams of attending: an unknown work being performed by a cast of largely unknown singers.

Assuming someone else will pick Leyla Gencer‘s legendary “Vil bastarda”, I’ll go with another clip featuring robust audience participation.

The Greatest Thing Ever (AKA Lisette Oropesa) in a stunning mad scene from Lucia di Lammermoor with the excellent Artur Rucinski and Roberto Tagliavini in an extremely effective production by David Alden at the Teatro Real in Madrid.

For me, Donizetti’s operas are all about the mad scenes.

Late Callas singing Maria from “Figlia del Reggimento” a role she wisely never attempted on stage.

Who knew that rehearing a performance you believed had become nothing more than a cherished memory would have such healing properties during a time of bereavement?

The ham in this pandemic-era let’s-put-on-a-show Elisir duet (from the Met at Home broadcast) may make the performance more sooey than sui generis. But I find it irresistible.

Well, it’s a clip from Mary Zimmermann‘s production of Lucia di Lammermoor… wait, wait, come back!

Does anyone remember Beverly Sills as the three Donizetti queens at NYCO? This made a huge impression on me.

The Met’s 2022 Lucia was divisive, to say the least, but it was the first time Lucia truly resonated with me.

In terms of elegance and beauty of execution, Renato Bruson is in a class by himself among Donizetti baritones.

Walking out of this Lucia performance from October 2010, my companion said to me, “No mystery who Seattle Opera’s Artist of the Year is going to be.” Aleksandra Kurzak did end up getting that award, to no one’s surprise!

My favorite scene in my favourite Donizetti opera. Even if she does go ahead and sing that damnable cabaletta, it’s Mariella Devia and she can do little RONG.

I’m convinced that someone else will claim this Donizetti opera before I do, but Maria Stuarda is definitely my very favorite Donizetti opera.

Kind of self-explanatory, but Maria Callas‘s mad scene in Anna Bolena has truly ruined this music for me.

A friend who frequents these pages recently turned me on to a Donizetti cantata that I had never heard of: his setting of the speech of Dante‘s Conte Ugolino.

Leyla Gencer cussing out Shirley Verrett’s Elisabetta so convincingly the audience spontaneously breaks out in applause and bravas.

In 1972, when I was 12 years old, my mother took me to the Salzburg Festival.

One of my favorite scenes from Donizetti is the Act I finale from Anna Bolena.

La Favorita is my favorita. Whether it’s Favorita or Favorite, I love them both.

Fiorenza Cossotto in her prime had few equals, particularly in the Italian repertoire