Cher Public

Sag, welch wunderbare Träume

Before audiences around the world saw his celebrated production of Wagner’s Parsifal, Toronto audiences were introduced to the operatic work of Quebec director François Girard at the Canadian Opera Company. He made his company debut with a striking double-bill of Stravinsky’s Oedipus Rex and Symphony of Psalms, and followed up with his distinctive Siegfried, with Canada’s set designer extraordinaire, Michael Levine, as his collaborative partner in all three.  

First seen in 2005, Siegfried returned as part of the Ring Cycle which opened the Four Seasons Centre the following year and makes a welcome return as a stand-alone production this season. (Last season saw a revival of Atom Egoyan’s Die Walküre and next season will see the return of Tim Albery’s Götterdämmerung. Alas, Michael Levine’s imaginative Das Rheingold has not been invited to the reunion). With a stronger cast than was seen and heard last time around, this is one of those rare revivals which has improved in its third outing.

Girard’s production is highly conceptual, framing the entire opera as a journey in Siegfried’s mind. The opera is presented a dream. All the characters wear white “pyjamas” with the exception of Brünnhilde who still wears her black Victorian dress in which she was put to sleep in Die Walküre. Siegfried sits on a giant tree stump (presumably the same one from which the sword Nothung was extracted) while a “tree” figuratively grows out of his head. The black-and-white set design provides an ideal canvass for David Finn’s evocative lighting.

Suspended in the tree’s branches are bits and pieces of the sets from the previous two operas of the cycle as well as dead bodies of the fallen. There are six acrobats sitting in the tree who come to life sporadically. Most prominent are a man and woman who represent Siegfried’s parents and respond when they are mentioned by the players below. Siegfried sits on the stump when the curtain rises and, when he’s supposed to leave the stage, returns to his spot. Mime and the bear are lowered from the top of the tree while Der Wanderer emerges from the tree trunk.

Speaking of the bear, this is the production’s most curious element. It is portrayed by a mime (George Molnar) in a bear suit. But he’s also dressed (deliberately ill-fittingly) with the same pyjamas as the rest of the cast. After Siegfried tells the bear to be off, he sticks around… for the entire act. (The Wanderer also sticks around after his scene, wandering across the set and eventually taking a seat leaning against the tree stump).

The concept is interesting but the execution is bewildering. No attempt is made to make the bear a menacing figure and instead he feebly hobbles around the stage observing the action. When I first saw the bear in the production’s premiere, I found him puzzling. This time, I found him tedious.

A hole in the ground serves as a forge and, for the Forging Scene, human hands appear from it bathed in red light. Like everything else in the act, the forging of the sword is giving a dreamy presentation. This act is successful in setting up the concept for the rest of the production but is less successful in portraying the drama. The first act of Siegfried features some of the most energetic and muscular music in the entire cycle—almost none of which is portrayed in the staging.

If the first act is visually striking but less than successful dramatically, the next two are something close to genius. The second act is the one that most comfortably works within the opera-as-dream concept. Here, the tree is inverted so that the audience is looking at it from above. The Forest Bird flies through the branches and the stage floor is littered with dead bodies. Among the bodies lies Alberich, keeping watch.

The coup de theatre is the presentation of the dragon. The six acrobats emerge from the stage floor and form a human pyramid. The dragon is not some giant prop but rather made up of people in Siegfried’s mind. As Fafner delivers his final lines, the pyramid slowly collapses and the top figure falls into Siegfried’s arms.

While the second act set is a visual explosion, the third act is completely bare. With the set immaculately dark, the only decorative feature is a pile of human bodies at the centre of the stage. The characters seem to float through space. When Siegfried approaches Brünnhilde’s rock, the bodies rise and form a circle, with red light flickering on their white costumes.

Brünnhilde lies at the centre of the circle, covered in a black drape. In the final duet, Siegfried and Brünnhilde never touch. They come close a few times but she pulls back. Only as the ecstatic closing measure of the opera ring out does the pair approach each other for an embrace. The dream ends as they kiss and the last chord strikes, setting the stage for the hero to go out into the real word.

Musically, this was a thrilling remount. Chief among the stars were the COC Orchestra under the direction of music director, Johannes Debus. Conducting his first Siegfried, Debus paced the drama expertly, capturing the mercurial qualities of the score while also evoking the grander moments with expansive phrasing. The orchestra responded splendidly, with the many competing leitmotivs vividly coming to life.

There was a brash confidence to the way tenor Stefan Vinke took on Siegfried’s punishing music. Most tenors skate over the difficult virtuoso opening line but he attacked it with gusto, culminating in a sustained (though too long) high C.  While he didn’t offer much by way of beautiful or varied singing (the few times he did made one wish for more), he displayed solid power and endless stamina.

This was a tireless performance in the best sense. I’ve never heard a Siegfried who sounded as fresh as his Brünnhilde in the final scene. In their great duet, the pair seemed to inspire each other to vocal heights with him taking the lead rather than keeping up with his newly awakened bride.

The tone lacked brilliance but had pleasing warmth and he thrived at the top of his voice, joining soprano Christine Goerke for a thrilling, sustained high C at the end. As an actor, Vinke was convincingly boisterous and portrayed the titular hero as a careless, if still likeable, jock. At curtain, he was given an immediate solo bow and received one of the loudest ovations I’ve heard in the Four Seasons Centre.

Goerke poured out a flood of warm tone on her opening “Heil dir, Sonne” but took a few minutes to warm up, her voice sounding unfocused at first. She conquered all of the high lying passages and her singing grew with intensity as the scene progressed. This was a very movingly portrayed Brünnhilde and I anxiously await her return in Götterdämmerung next year.

When I heard Alan Held as Kurwenal a couple of years ago, I thought that I’d like to hear his Wotan and he did not disappoint, pouring out reams of bronzed, ringing tone as Der Wanderer. The extreme ends of his voice lost colour and power but this was an imposing performance, both vocally and physically.

As Mime, Wolfgang Albinger-Sperrhacke sang with ideal German declamation and delivered precision (and often amusing) acting, while Chrisopher Purves powerfully embodied Alberich’s desperation and desire. It was a pleasure to listen to contralto Meredith Arwady dig into Erda’s low notes while soprano Jaqueline Woodley sang with an appropriately silvery tone as the Forest Bird. The only consistent cast member of this production’s three incarnations, bass Philip Enns once again growled impressively as Fafner.

In the final verdict, Girard’s vision of the story as a dream in Siegfried’s mind works if not taken too strictly. Taken literally, the concept can be confounding (Can Alberich exist in Siegfried’s mind considering the two never meet? Is that why he wears a dark overcoat over his pyjamas when no one else does?). However, taken as a loose framework for Siegfried’s journey of self-discovery, it works in a thought-provoking manner, satisfyingly developing along its long arc.

Photos: Michael Cooper

  • PCally

    VERY excited for Goerke. I agree with Bill and Camille that her voice is tad too tense for me and she’s not exactly glamerous. But I don’t know that I’ve ever heard the roles she’s been singing sung with such scrupulous musicality, care, and richness in live performa

    • PCally

      *whoops accidently submitted before finishing.

      …in live performance. And while she’s not inherently charismatic she NEVER just phones it in. I hope she continues to have success.

      • John L

        Her upper register is a bit tense. I liken it to a cargo ship trying to fit through a Venician canal. But her middle and upper middle voice is very rich and carries forward (also her lower register is weighty too, which makes me think she could have a career as a mezzo after singing the dramatic soprano roles). But it is true there is a bit of a shift beyond the high G or high A. Also her voice is much better in person than on recording (I guess it’s true about what they say of big voices). And although she may not be glamourous, I do find her quite dramatic and charismatic in her interpretation of a role (Dyers wife, Ariadne, Brunnhilde, Elektra).

        • antikitschychick

          +1. I too look forward to hearing her (as well as Nina Stemme!) in other roles besides Turandot and thanks for this great review kash. Very vivid and detailed.

        • also her lower register is weighty too, which makes me think she could have a career as a mezzo after singing the dramatic soprano roles)

          Yes, based on how her voice sounds now, I think she can have a fairly seamless transition to mezzo roles. I imagine that she’ll first drop the most high-lying stuff and stick to things like Ariadne and maybe Ortrud, and then eventually switch to things like Fricka, Die Amme, Klytämnestra.

          • John L

            I realized after I wrote that, one can never predict with the human voice! She could transition NOW to mezzo roles. But who knows after singing the really heavy stuff for 3,5,10 years, who can predict what her voice (middle and lower register) is like then. But based on the little snippets out there, I would’ve loved to hear her Ortrud in Houston (I didn’t know her back then). And playing a villain, that would’ve been fun!

            • antikitschychick

              I agree with you John. I think she can make the transition now as well, or rather than transition maybe add a few lower-lying roles to her rep.

            • John L

              AKC, yeah it seems like she has quite a few Rings lined up for the next 3 to 5 years at the Lyric Opera of Chicago, Met, Bayreuth, and maybe even other places, so that’ll probably be most of what she’s doing. Also it looks like she’s adding Isolde into her repertory too. She probably won’t go into the lower stuff any time soon.

            • SilvestriWoman

              Goerke is singing Cassandre next season here in Chicago.

        • Flora del Rio Grande

          I, too, wish Mme Goerke well — she deserves success
          after a lot of hard work. But I am not buying her
          top register. Even in Eboli’s aria tonite at Tucker
          she was flat. The extremely vibrating tongue is very
          worrisome. I wish any vocal technicians present would
          explain what is going on there. She seems to be using
          the tongue as an extension of the vocal cords, which
          it is not. Worried about the Met Ring in 2017.

          • la vociaccia

            It’s not a massively complex or uncommon phenomenon; she produces her current sound by driving her voice at full force and the tension is causing her tongue to shake.

  • Porgy Amor

    What a great piece, Ali. Thanks for this.

  • Here’s a nice promo video that show the staging in action.


  • phoenix

    kash: so thorough is this review it makes me feel like I saw it myself just from reading it here.
    Many thanks!
    -- Very happy to hear about Vinke’s success. I liked him from the 1st time I heard him years ago as Rienzi.

  • Talk of the Town

    Thanks for this review! Wish I’d been there.

  • Alex Baker

    Ditto on the great review! Traveling for 20 minutes of Goerke-hilde seems excessive but I see Houston flights ARE pretty cheap right now…

    • Thingsaregettingbetterdownhere

      Alex Baker: Sunday and weekday tickets for HGO’s Siegfried are plentiful and less-expensive than other nights. I felt like you did about 20 minutes of Goerke, but you do get to hear the rest of Siegfried, too.

      BTW, I don’t know if you’ve been to Houston, but the airports are far from downtown. Hobby is closest.

  • John L

    I forgot to ask, what is written in the score for Siegfried on the final note? A low C? I’ve only heard low Cs in recordings. But I guess if you somehow have any reserve left at the end, why not go for a high C and knock everyone’s socks off!

    • HiggsBoson

      The Dover score indicates a middle C and no optional notation for a high C. However, Brunnhilde has written both the high C and the lower C as well.

      • John L

        Interesting how Wagner gives both options for Brunnhilde. Nowadays everyone expects a high C. In a Flagstad recording I heard she opted for the lower C. I’ve always wondered about Wagner’s relatively sparing use of the high C. Was it because he was understanding of the type of singers needed to sing his works or because he didn’t want to “copy” the Italian style.

  • Clivia

    Great review! I saw this production Friday night and agree that Vinke has endless stamina and is a good actor. He got laughs. He recieved a huge standing ovation for his solo bow. All the men sounded great. The surtitles for “Heil dir, Sonne” were projected several moments early then hastily covered up followed by silence. It was a relief when Brunnhilde started to sing. C.G.’s voice really warmed up and her performance took off when she finally got up off the ground and started to move around. I started to wonder if she needed help getting off the floor because of the train on her dress in addition to the huge fabric sheet used to cover her up. The leads were both terrific at the end. Five hours well spent.