Headshot of La Cieca

Cher Public

  • PCally: Moore was excellent and had a super high c. But I think Harteros has the more distinct voice and... 11:21 AM
  • Archaeopteryx: Don’t know about his Radames, but Kunde was an excellent Manrico at the Fenice last... 11:19 AM
  • aulus agerius: I don’t hear Margaret or Leontyne in there. But there do seem to be a lot of dead... 11:17 AM
  • perfidia: Price? 10:50 AM
  • aulus agerius: I don’t ‘know’ any of them except Caballe. My favorites are 17 (Milanov?)... 10:41 AM
  • Poison Ivy: So here you go. httpv://www.youtub e.com/watch?v=rs5n -U7t61I 10:38 AM
  • aulus agerius: I did not hear Harteros’ as that bad – certainly not like a cat with it’s... 10:23 AM
  • Krunoslav: Any selection omitting Hammond and Rutter is not worth one’s time. 10:18 AM
  • pavel: Listening to all those clips just makes me wonder: is there anyone who does not come off the rails a... 10:17 AM
  • m. croche: Happy Birthday to Alexander Goedicke. Natasha’s Romance from “At the CrossroadsR... 10:16 AM

Canard season

La Cieca has her old, old, old friend Enzo Bordello (pictured, left) to thank for this week’s canard, or rather, carnards, as Enzo has delivered a delicious brace of blunders.

First misconception: “Violetta’s joyful cabaletta ‘Sempre libera’.” There is nothing joyous about what she is expressing. It is a death wish to annihilate herself through hard living. The manic character of the music is ironic, not literal.

And canard the second: Cio-Cio-San kills herself “because of a broken heart” or as an act of manipulation to make Pinkerton feel bad. No, she kills herself as an act of self-effacement to eradicate any trace of her son’s ties to Japan, so that he can acculturate neatly and easily into his new life in America, freed of the stigma of being viewed as a biracial bastard. And the usual reply to this is: “Well, how can that be? He must look Asian.” Well, no. Puccini and his librettist are explicit about the boy’s blonde hair and blue eyes. Genetically improbable, perhaps, but there it is.

51 comments

  • La Valkyrietta says:

    One can read between the lines, but why ignore the actual lines and scenes of the opera, explicitly placed in ti? There are multiple motivations for any human action, so perhaps the canard is just fixing the attention on one of those and ignoring the others, as important as the highlighted motivation might be. Perhaps in the end Cio-Cio-San kills herself because Yamadori is no Brad Pitt. :(