The Quantification of the Diva: Upon Reflection

And the mirror replied, “I’ll tell you right after the jump!”
What a week it’s been, cher public, and La Cieca (speaking on behalf of herself and Jay Caspian Kang) only hopes you’ve been enlightened by our little étude as much as we have found pleasure in bringing a little joy into your humdrum lives.
The scores have been tallied, and all that is left is to view the bubble graphs.
So, now that everything is settled, La Cieca is ready to entertain questions or to…. what’s that? You say the bubble graphs are less than clear in delineating a winner or winners? Oh, well, you’re right, of course, but aren’t all those colorful little bubbles lovely? How they remind La Cieca of the poster for the 1971 revival of No, No, Nanette!
Dear Loni Zoe Ackerman—whatever is she doing with herself these days? ….Oh, yes, of course: the diva rankings!
CLASSIC DIVAS
| RANK | DIVA | SCORE |
| 1 | Leontyne Price | 830 |
| (tie) 2 | Montserrat Caballé | 825 |
| (tie) 2 | Renata Scotto | 825 |
| 4 | Leonie Rysanek | 820 |
| 5 | Jessye Norman | 800 |
| 6 | Régine Crespin | 770 |
| 7 | Tatiana Troyanos | 725 |
| 8 | Joan Sutherland | 710 |
| 9 | Christa Ludwig | 640 |
| 10 | Marilyn Horne | 580 |
| 11 | Hildegard Behrens | 520 |
| 12 | Mirella Freni | 495 |
CONTEMPORARY DIVAS
| RANK | DIVA | SCORE |
| 1 | Edita Gruberova | 725 |
| 2 | Angela Gheorghiu | 705 |
| 3 | Anna Netrebko | 690 |
| 4 | Karita Mattila | 680 |
| 5 | Renée Fleming | 675 |
| 6 | Cecilia Bartoli | 605 |
| 7 | Waltraud Meier | 590 |
| 8 | Dolora Zajick | 530 |
| 9 | Joyce DiDonato | 520 |
| 10 | Natalie Dessay | 480 |
So, what have we learned, cher public?
Well, to begin with: it’s easier to be an older diva than a younger diva. Age adds to the “legendary” quality.
Retirement from the hurly-burly of the operatic stage perhaps adds a luster of soft focus to a diva, glossing over flaws that may have been more apparent when witnessed in real time.
Emotional Journey counts for a lot. Kunst and Stimm are about equally important, but you’d better have a lot of one or the other, or you’re no diva.
And for heaven’s sake, don’t be stingy with the Scandale!
La Cieca now invites the cher public to discuss the rankings, about which she is sure you will all be in complete agreement.
(Photo: Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera)
Jay Caspian Kang, who has delighted us so often at Free Darko, also may be heard tweeting at maxpower51.
La Cieca
James Jorden (who wrote under the names "La Cieca" and "Our Own JJ") was the founder and editor of parterre box. During his 20 year career as an opera critic he wrote for the New York Times, Opera, Gay City News, Opera Now, Musical America and the New York Post. He also raised his voice in punditry on National Public Radio. From time to time he directed opera, including three unsuccessful productions of Don Giovanni. He also contributed a regular column on opera for the New York Observer. James died in October 2023.
-
Topics: diva, diva diva diva diva diva, Quantification of the Diva
-
People: Angela Gheorghiu, Anna Netrebko, Cecilia Bartoli, Christa Ludwig, Dolora Zajick, Edita Gruberova, Hildegard Behrens, Jay Caspian Kang, Jessye Norman, Joyce DiDonato, Karita Mattila, Leonie Rysanek, Leontyne Price, Marilyn Horne, Mirella Freni, Montserrat Caballé, Natalie Dessay, Régine Crespin, Renata Scotto, Renée Fleming, Tatiana Troyanos, Waltraud Meier
-
Places & Organizations: Metropolitan Opera


