Cher Public

  • nalasa1: I remember seeing a tryout of “Subways are for Sleeping” in Philadelphia. I loved it, especially Phyllis Newman. Yet... 12:05 PM
  • Camille: Beati Voi!! I would love to see that island adjacent to Siracusa, among many other things—and must just briefly pop in to tell... 12:03 PM
  • Feldmarschallin: ‘Ditto Emily Magee.’ Well that isn’t putting the bar very high is it? Emily Magee can be put in the... 11:40 AM
  • Batty Masetto: Well, kerflooey. Lorenzo, I tried replying here but it wound up at the end of the thread. 11:40 AM
  • Batty Masetto: Lorenzo, how kind of you to stand up for me. And I utterly share your fascination with Sicily. Some years ago I toured... 11:38 AM
  • Batty Masetto: Thank you, Mrs. JC. No harm done, but I didn’t want to let the record stand the way it was. 11:33 AM
  • Cicciabella: I don’t think there was anything strange in Wilson’s reaction to the parterre review. Her mistake was to react... 11:12 AM
  • lorenzo.venezia: armer, you’re on your own, baby ;-) 10:02 AM

Tout gai!

snagglepussIn honor of the 40th anniversary of Gay Pride (the 40th official anniversary, anyway) coming up this weekend, La Cieca proposes this week’s YouTube contest theme: “Tout gai!”  

Your task is to find and to properly embed a YouTube video exemplifying “Tout gai!”, then append a few sentences explaining why your choice is indeed le plus gai.  Allow La Cieca to demonstrate:

We will pass briefly over the obvious camp value of the dragocious interpretation of 18th century costume and stage demeanor (while admitting that Beverly Sills rocks both) and the ornamentation Roland Gagnon madly bedazzles over Handel’s melody; the point here is the gaiety (in the pre-cocksucking sense of the word) with which the singer sails through the music.  To me, the deepest loss in the Sills package in her last five years of career wasn’t the wobble or the hardening of the top notes, it was the dimming of her sheer giggling joy in singing. And that’s why I like to remember her at her gayest here.

So, go look for a YouTube clip of your favorite “Tout gai!” moment, and post it in the comments section for this posting, along with your commentary, by midnight on Sunday, June 27. The clip and comment La Cieca judges the best (and her whim is final) will receive a copy of the newly-released DVD The Metropolitan Opera Gala 1991: 25th Anniversary at Lincoln Center, documenting this performance. (If the winner resides outside the United States, La Cieca reserves the right to substitute an gift certificate of equivalent value.)

Now, gai it up!


  • OpinionatedNeophyte says:

    I have three entries:

    Way back in 1984. Maybe her best rendition and also the knowledge that she’s more than a little bit c-c-c-crazy makes you wonder does the “giggle” in her sound come from joy or from her fantasizing about torturing costume people? Its fun either way really.

    For her total non-caring at all about the correct pronunciation of French vowels. Its all about interpolating those high notes isn’t it Ms. Peters? Go head with your bad pronouncing but amazing singing self.

    Odd choice I know. Do I normally think of sheer uncontrollable joy when I think of June Anderson? Not so much. Its hard to forget her bitch face + golf claps after Battle’s O Luce during the much sought after Gala video. But in the mid 80s before she figured out that American opera house GMs were going to collectively screw she seems pretty happy. Plus props for reproducing note for note those famous Sutherland interpolations from the Primma Donna album. Yay Joanie!

    • OpinionatedNeophyte says:

      Oh and for just sheer joy in vocal emission I have to add this non-operatic entry. Stunning.

    • Valmont says:

      For sheer joy of singing as well

      • Harry says:

        Valmont; Do you really want us to loathe and detest Berlioz? Wankright’s voice is positioned down ‘in his guts’.

    • NYCOQ says:

      Oh this was worth it just for the dress alone…

    • ilpenedelmiocor says:

      Love June Anderson but the dress makes her look as if she’s going to a Halloween party dressed as an ejaculation.

  • Maury D says:

    I hate that this is just in stills.

  • Maury D says:

    Wait one more, because what is more gayerer than Cathy Berberian?

  • Kilian says:

    Purcell’s The Fairy Queen being only a semi-opera, this probably doesn’t qualify as ‘tout’: Jonathan Best wooing and winning Michael Chance. And some dancing when the singing’s done.

  • Orlando Furioso says:

    Unfortunately the version of “YMCA” that Goldie Hawn did on her joint TV special with Liza Minnelli in 1980 doesn’t seem to be on YouTube. If it were, it would be a strong contender for gayest thing ever: the initial fakeout preceding it with the verse to “A Foggy Day” (“I was a stranger in the city…”), the 6 eager backup boys joining her in workout and shower (with suggestions of bare butts in the reflective surround), the irrepressible merriment of it all… damn, I’ve got to find a copy of that monstrosity.

  • MontyNostry says:

  • tosca_fairy says:

    I can’t believe I almost forgot about this one (and I saw it in Munich in Feb two years ago:

    Bugs bunny is always fun and campy, too; a true inspiration as a child:

  • PirateJenny says:

    Here to start the sub-category “men in speedos doing le hully-gully”:

  • Mine requires a long explanation. the song is originally from some boy band O-Zone sung in Romanian. The original is pretty gay all by itself:

    Then come this duo of comedians from Spain and since the song is pretty gay and it sounds as if they are singing Pluma Pluma gay (in the Spanish countries gay men are compared to both butterflies and ducks, the last one for the feathers) they came up with this parody. (it is subtitled)

    Then it had to make it to the Antilles, and for that Mala Fe, the Dominican merenguero gave it the Caribbean spice: It must be noted that Mala Fe is straight and at the end of the video he says With all due respect to the gay community: Be happy. We love you.

    Well, the crazy had already been born and there are many people doing the Numa Numa Gay or the Pluma Pluma Gay. My favorites (and the gayest of them all) are:

    So I will submit that the gayest thing on YouTube is the hole Numa Numa/Pluma Pluma gay craze. It has given us plenty of straight cute boys gaying it up and letting it all hang for the camera.

    • armerjacquino says:

      Plus, of course, there was something of a scandal when it was rumoured that two of the singers from O-Zone were actually sub-dom rent boys…

      I’ve posted my entry a couple of times before, but if a six foot tall mezzo who has played both Sally Bowles in Stockholm and Annio at Salzburg singing an opera-based dance track at the Eurovision Song Contest isn’t gay, then neither am I.

  • PirateJenny says:

    And now something for the ladies: the fabulously talented Jane Morgan, now somewhat overlooked but who I consider one of the greatest pop/classical singers of the 20th century, and some dancing ladies shot from below their mini-skirts. Glimpses of underpants are to be had. Jane appears to be enjoying the girls, rather than her generic male dinner companion. And her voice is gorgeous… c’est si bon, ladies!

  • SilvestriWoman says:

    How can we not include these gay-gay-gay gems? Of course, they’re from Maestro Wenarto! It’s so hard to select three, let alone one, but here goes!




  • kashania says:

    My non-operatic entry. Self-explanatory really.

  • DrugProduct says:

    I don’t know if this meets this contest’s definition of gay, but this clip brings me to tears, tears of pure joy, the type of joy that only elevated artistry can bring:

    And to get some more flavor of “Priscilla, Queen of the Desert”, here’s another fabulous, lovely and gay clip, non operatic this time but highly musical nonetheless:

    • callasorphan says:

      I love Priscilla too and view it often to “brighten” my day.

      • Harry says:

        What is even campier in many ways is the same director’s next film ‘Welcome to Woop Woop’. It is still a mystery to me how the film was allowed to use the whole Rodgers & Hammerstein Songbook and send them up, stupid. Just take the scenes of ‘producing dog food with chain saws on kangeroos’,then shoveling the slop into cans against the song ‘Happy Talk’, or the song ‘You Will Never Walk Alone’ used for the gala crowd parade funeral of the town’s farting matriarch. AS she is carried on a dais -going to be cremated up on the yearly rubbish tip bonfire on the mountainous piles of the town’s rubbish.
        That film is pure mind blowing cool….glad I own the DVD. I love watching rather staid minded friends ‘ go white’ if I show them the film.
        No wonder as related by its director: a big Hollywood studio, requested a copy of the film , thinking they had another box office ‘Priscilla’ on their hands….then ‘piss weak’ ,refused to take any of his further calls.

        • BETSY_ANN_BOBOLINK says:

          God1 “Welcome to Woop Woop.” One of my all-time great something or others. And not just for the erstwhile Mr. Applegate, although he figures into the equation.

  • Ok, I see now that one needn’t hold back. Soo….

    First is in two clips -- Diana Damrau’s Zerbinetta. She brings the music back to speech and laughter so well. I tried to find a video to no avail. Got to see her this year for the first time at Carnegie Hall with James Levine. She sang Strauss lieder and then this, and I was HOOKED!
    Part 1:

    Part 2:

    Ohhh so happy gay!! Infectiously gay!!

    My favorite Glitter and Be Gay

    And then… look how CUTE she can be!


    • PirateJenny says:

      there are some things so awesome it is to difficult to believe the universe could conspire to create them.

  • Now, if we are talking joieux de vive -gai- I think Bartoli can be set with the best of them.

    First the aria Yo que soy contrabandista from the Manuel Garcia opera (or operetta/zarzuela) El poeta calculista. How could you not want to put a throw around your waist and start hitting the floor with your feet? What I like about this rendition is the joy she brings to it. You can see she believes in this material.

    but then again, not many can match her Non piu mesta

    • OpinionatedNeophyte says:

      I want to love her but those weird clicks and pops, I feel sometimes like I’m listening to an east African language :)

      • MontyNostry says:

        Isn’t Xhosa, from South Africa, the one with the clicks and pops?
        I find Bartoli hard to tolerate in any language. She is a circus act.

        • PirateJenny says:

          After years of listening to her I have not come to any conclusion about her. When she is forced to sing something slower, without all the hhhuuuuhhh-huh-huh-huhs she can be quite lovely -- if I close my eyes. I propose that she is a diva with, as Dr. Repertoire posted on this site, “no gay friends”. Aside from the crazy eye popping and tourettic jaw movement, those dresses! that hair! Seriously, does she think her concerts are a come-as-your-favourite-Dynasty-character party? she is far too young to wear such hideous 80′s numbers, and she is desperate need of a haircut. Get some Kiehl’s silk groom, girl -- and NEVER EVER wear a hair clip to a concert again!

        • ilpenedelmiocor says:

          Was JUST gonna post “no gay friends”….

  • Kernita Makilla says:

  • louannd says:

    OK -- I just want to say = HAPPY GAY PRIDE to all!

    and representing the ya know contingent --

    with one of the most beautiful pieces of music I have ever heard with appropriate womanly passion and badass see through costume -- Janet Baker and Ileana Cortrubas

    and for the butchier side of things

  • Olivero is my Drug of Choice says:

    I think this may be the gayest clip ever, PERFECTION in Diva Crossover:

    • callasorphan says:

      Perfection indeed.

      • OpinionatedNeophyte says:

        OMG, I LOVE this clip and even thought of putting it on. I actually get misty as she sings this, its wonderfully heartfelt and the final note, ugh. I can’t really quite queen out enough for this woman.

    • actfive says:

      Thrilling, goose-bump inducing…I have loved this clip for years!

  • brooklynpunk says:

    I KNOW…”They are JUST VERY good …FRIENDS….”


  • Donna Carlo says:

    A tad too serious for the gai, gai, gai, theme of this thread; on the other hand, it would be too entirely unfair to bypass ALL of Adès’s Powder Her Face, where even the non-transvestites are so very drag. I was looking for the famous fellatio scene, but YouTube is prudish I guess, so this sunny snippet of the rainbow will have to do: