Cher Public

Now, that’s how it’s done!

jake_gLa Cieca proposes a new weekly competition: she provides the theme, you provide the examples. This week: “Now, that’s how it’s done!”

The concept is: if you want to know how an aria or operatic scene should be performed, look no further. Your task is to find and to properly embed a YouTube video exemplifying some operatic superlative, then append a few sentences explaining why your choice is indeed the best of the best.

La Cieca will now offer an example.

Everything about this Renata Tebaldi clip if pretty fabulous including (especially) the hair, but what really is “how it’s done” here is the expert and fearless use of chest voice. Especially impressive is the soprano’s deliberate contrast of timbre between the hard, snarling chest tone and the limpid mezza voce in the middle register. Some Giocondas are good at expressing rage, others vulnerability, but Tebaldi can modulate between the two almost instantaneously without sacrificing the quality of the voice.

So, go look for a YouTube clip of your favorite “Now, that’s how it’s done!” moment, and post it in the comments section for this posting, along with your commentary, by midnight on Sunday, June 20. The clip and comment La Cieca judges the best (and her whim is final) will receive a copy of the newly-released DVD The Metropolitan Opera Gala 1991: 25th Anniversary at Lincoln Center, documenting this performance. (If the winner resides outside the United States, La Cieca reserves the right to substitute an gift certificate of equivalent value.)

So, show La Cieca how it’s done!

  • here is a late additin to the list, but I think no one has touched this selection yet:

    This is the one Renee Fleming recording I openly love. While most sopranos start with a detached quality to their performance, Fleming is immediately distraught and I think it serves the music and the text much better.

    • louannd

      While this isn’t a bad recording by any means, I think this performance by Elly Ameling shows much more control and a sustained despair that builds until the exhaustive final conclusion. She is not the least bit detached.

      • Agreed, this is a nice build up. I like the build up that Ameling takes and the nervous intensity that Fleming bring to that brutal ending.

      • Bill

        Surprisingly prefer Fleming here at the faster tempo than Ameling -- but the singer for this song
        is Irmgard Seefried (more than a half dozen
        versions of her rendition available here and there not as fast as Fleming’s) both for the controlled passion, limpid tone, superb diction and then the impulsive climaxes. Seefried truly tells a story as she sings. Seefried sang it at her Town Hall debut in 1951 tearing out the hearts of everyone in the audience after which Elisabeth Schumann, who was in attendance, supposedly asked “Was I ever so good as she ?” When asked in an interview years later who were the finest lieder singers Christa Ludwig responded, “for Schubert Seefried, for Hugo Wolf
        Schwarzkopf and for Brahms, me”

        • louannd

          Thanks Bill -- you said it better than I ever could have so it must be so! I don’t like the faster tempo though. I think the slower tempo leaves more room for a crisper interpretation from Dalton Baldwin.

  • rapt

    I’m glad we’ve expanded the field beyond opera arias, since this gives me a chance to offer an example of my all-time favorite singing. What makes it great? The variety and control of her dynamics and vocal colors, the ease of her movement between registers, and primarily, of course, the way she uses her skill to achieve what is for me the most effective tone for this song, perfectly judging the balance of sentiment and restraint so that she avoids either preciosity or bathos.

    • peter

      One of my all time favorite recordings.

    • Arianna a Nasso

      The most erotic voice preserved on disc. I always need to wipe myself off and have a cigarette after hearing her.

      • MontyNostry

        Regine divine.

    • Bill

      I do not believe anyone has ever surpassed Crespin in these Berlioz songs. She is haunting to hear -- touching beyond belief. It is surprising but many of my favorite sopranos had ravishingly beautiful middle voices and perhaps (at least later in their
      careers) short tops -- Crespin was one, and Seefried, Jurinac, Tebaldi, de los Angeles, Pilou, Janowitz.

    • Violetta

      Headsup -- I’m re-uploading this (and a lot of other things), hoping to trick youtube into giving them better sound quality…

  • DrugProduct

    This is how you do a prayer, and hold a pianissimo on a high note:

    • Donna Carlo

      From her lips to God’s ear and now, fortunately, to ours. Thank you so much!

  • poisonivy

    I’m going to say that when she was on, Leontyne Price could school sopranos on “how it’s done” like no other:

    And here are Sutherland and Gedda in La Sonnambula, truly showing how “Son geloso” should be done. I love their simultaneous descending trills.

    • That Marietta’s Lied isn’t necessarily top-drawer Price for me. But the “Depuis le jour” (which I’ve listened to many times) is a master class in floating high notes — one ravishing example after another. And thanks for the Sutherland/Gedda clip — exquisite.

  • ilpenedelmiocor

    Only three words for this one: legato, floated pianissimi.

    And it’s not yet midnight my time, mind.

    • Batty Masetto

      Exquisite singing. Also, how not to direct a magical scene. Definitive proof that lousy directing did not originate with Regie. I felt I could hardly hear her because of the visual distraction of all those urchins galumphing pointlessly around the set. Guarda mamma, sono nella TV!!

      • And how about that prosthetic nose?

        • ilpenedelmiocor

          LOL yeah, it’s remarkably convex compared to the 2.0 version.

      • armerjacquino

        BM- have the aria on its own, peerlessly sung, without any distracting galumphers.

        • Batty Masetto

          Also lovely AJ, thank you so much. But as long as I don’t watch the galumphers, I think Moffo’s version floats even more ethereally, don’t you?

        • And out of the confines of the contest. How about this one?

    • louannd

      fourth and fifth -- fairy princess -- incredibly beautiful.

  • ilpenedelmiocor

    And this is, quite simply, how it’s done: with sheer guts. Great technique doesn’t hurt. But all the others wtih great technique don’t even come close on this one.

    • callasorphan

      What a wonderful start to my day--my mom showing just how it should be done; she truly was glorious!

      • Actually, as much as I love Callas in Bolenna I think she was surpassed by both Sills and Gruberoba in this Cabaletta. They both bring technical and stylistic assurance to spare.

        • No doubt that the glory of Callas’s final scene is the recit and cavatina that come before. The phrasing and the emotional investment become one seamless whole — what every singer should aspire to:

          (This is a studio recording as opposed to more famous live La Scala recording).

        • ilpenedelmiocor

          Yeah, but that’s exactly what I meant — despite the fact that Sills and Gruberova may be technically more skilled in this (though the breaks between Sills’ very different sounding registers are exposed here, and Gruberova always sounds shrill to me), with more tricks, for me they don’t capture the raw emotional power of Callas. They just sound petulant while Callas rages. To be fair, these are both studio recordings, and I intentionally chose Callas’ live 1957 La Scala performance, even though it’s technically less polished than the 1958 studio recording, which I will add here.

        • Actually, Whils Sills’ is a studio recording, Gruberoba’s recording of Bolena was captured live.

  • Cocky Kurwenal

    Since we’ve decided forays into non-operatic repertoire are OK, here is some Janowitz singing Bach. Neither the artist nor the composer are terribly near the top of any of my lists, but I came across this recently and it is just sublime:

    I also think it’s a bit of a scandal that a thread like this so far doesn’t feature any Pavarotti (unless I didn’t notice):

  • enzo

    Ponselle in Ernani.

    • ilpenedelmiocor

      Nice. Also love this version (by which I don’t mean to say I think it’s better, I just like it also).

      • callasorphan

        My goodness, how time slips away. I remember when that recording was released in this country (1958 or 1959) on Angel records. OF COURSE, I was first in line to purchase it (the album “Mad Scenes”) and played it so much and so loud that my real mom tried to throw it out the window. (I think the neighbors complained) Great photos too. Thanks for the memories.

        • callasorphan

          My memory is bad--it was NOT the “Mad Scene” album but the Verdi album that came out the same time. I purchased them at the same time much to my real mom’s horror. She was not an opera fan and felt that I listened to that “Callas woman” far too much.

    • ilpenedelmiocor

      And surprisingly not bad at all, all things considered.

  • enzo

    Ponselle as Gioconda.

  • luvtennis

    The greatest singing that the we have had perhaps ever.

    Certainly, Mr. HvK thinks so.

    • callasorphan

      I agree. Whenever I hear in this performance all that I can say is OMG!!

      • MontyNostry

        She is simply gobsmacking there. I was raving about this performance to someone just yesterday, as it happens. Does anyone know whether the audio was recorded at the same time as the video? It doesn’t look as though she is doing it to a backing track.

        • I think it is actually dubbed. Either that or the voices were recorded separately and added as a separate entity to the video.

          If you compare it to other videos of the period (actually almost anything like that up to the 80’s you will notice the difference (look for example at the Caballe Preghiera from Stuarda)

        • Let me add one layer to this: Part 2 of the aria does indeed answer whether the artists were sinked to a sountrack. The video shows some sinking issues:

        • luvtennis


          I agree that they lipsynched some of the film but much of it is not.

          More to the point -- she sang it this well EVERY FREAKING TIME SHE SANG IT!!!!!

          My mother heard her do this in London in the 70’s. There were spontaneous outbursts (mostly gasps) after the requiem aeternam section. Price was furious until she realized that folks just couldn’t help themselves

        • But saying that she sang it like this is not the same as saying that she was singing WHEN she was in front of the camera; those are 2 different statements, completely unrelated to each other.

          I am not offering any opinion as to whether I find this performance acceptable, I am offering a fact that there are sinking issues and it sounds like this the performers were not singing in front of the cameras, but lip-sinking.

          I am sure there is documentation out there that would tell us one way or another. I seem to recall that HvK did not want to record this live and insisted on creating a soundtrack to which the singers performed.

          I will let the HvK experts and probably Alto, with her recording industry expertise clear the air and correct us both.

    • Simply divine. This DVD gets a lot of play in my home. Cossotto and Ghiaurov are magnificent as well. Pavarotti is great too but falls just shy of the other three.

      • luvtennis

        The utter precision of Price and Cossotto is almost amazing. How on earth could such amply endowed singers blend so perfectly?

        Complete control of overtones. The sort of control that most singers don’t even bother to achieve unless they are singing Bach.

        BUT finally, what makes this so great for me is that she sings the score like it was embedded in her DNA. Every legato marking, every dynamic, every expressive marking. Legato is maintained across the broadest intervals, and unlike Caballe, whose pianissimi had a disembodied quality and were not produced the same way as the rest of her voice, the softest tones and the loudest tones are supported in exactly the same manner so her dynamic control is complete down to the semiquaver.

        That is what you can do with a true legato. I would post some Sutherland that demonstrates the same mastery but youtube is acting up.

      • luvtennis


        I think the answer is that there was a performance recorded in its entirety both visually and aurally- there are times when that is clear and accords with what I have read of the film. That said, I think that HvK insisted on redoing certain parts of the visual portion of film for one reason or another. It is the reshoot part that results in the lypsynching to the original aural recording of the performance.

        So you have mostly a film of a concert with the soundtrack from that concert. You also have some separately filmed sections where they had to lipsynch to the original recorded performance.

  • poisonivy

    Here’s an oldie but goodie:

  • Violetta

    Late, but here’s my contribution:
    (I never seem to have time to keep up with all the goings on at Parterre -- what a great thread!)

    For floated legato, dynamic control, and the supported decrescendo 1:55 -- 2:05.

    • CL in DC

      Thanks for this clip. It’s one of my favorite moments in the opera and that was a beautiful rendition.

    • I have to say that this man was wonderful. Too bad his mind got the best of him. If there was ever a tenor who could do everything it was him. He had the agilita, the power and the command of the style. Listen to that french and the grasp of the style.


      • mrmyster

        Lindoro, could you explain “his mind got the best of him?”
        That would be rather unusual in a tenor, no? :)
        What did you mean?

        • He was known as Il pazzo for his erratic behavior. Here are some stories:

          1. Somewhere in Europe (Vienna?) after singing 4 consecutive high C’s in the Riddle scene in Turandot he stoppped the conductor to tell the audience it was OK to applud beause puccini had written a pause in the music.

          2. He was known to make remarks that one of the 3 tenors (Domingo?) was looking to put a hit on him and kill him

          there’s evidence of his erratic behavior too:

          I am not a mental health professional, but I think that the pressure got to him, probably compounded by the fact that he saw himself as better than any of the 3 tenors and resented the fame and adulation that they received.

          In certain ways he was right, he had a better technique than both Domingo and Carreras (He never lost his high C, wereas both Domingo and Carraras had it for like a weekend and then lost it permanently)and he had a more varied repertoire than Pavarotti and had a better grasp of languages and styles. In all reality, the Pav was a slob who got away with it because he had a fabulous voice. Pav would not sing in anything but Italian and his recordings of anything else show that his master of languages was rudimentary at best. Pavarotti was not very curious about adding roles, avoided Rossini like the plague and sang only 2 Mozart roles. Also The Pav was not a great musician and didn’t particulary cared for the process of learning music; I am am sure that irked Bonisolli quite a lot.

          When it is all said and done, pound for pound, Bonisolli was their equal and in some areas the better one but he didn’t have the “sex appeal” than the other 3 had. I am sure this affected his psyche and his behavior.

  • Tristan_und

    Is it my imagination or did the clip of Troyanos singing the last scene of Les Troyens vanish from the face of this thread? Copyright issues, La Cieca? Grazie.

  • dsjmfa
  • CL in DC

    I’m late to the game, but I had to throw this in. I love Ariadne auf Naxos. I’ve only seen it live twice, but I’ve youtubed the heck out of “Ein Schones war” and “Es Gibt ein Reich.” If there’s a better version than Jessye Norman’s from the Met, then I haven’t heard it (but I’m willing to listen). Her breath control is amazing. The drama and power are there, yet there’s still a delicateness to it.

    And THAT is how Ariadne is done!


      Another thing I like about this clip is that she does not make it look easy. It’s difficult music, and she knows it, and we know it, but unlike so many who work so hard just to get through it, she works hard to get it right. There’s a difference.

      • luvtennis


        You are just soooo cool.

        Really. How do you manage to be so funny, articulate, humane and wacky at the same time.

        You may laugh, but I have always felt that Ms Manners is one of the underated pleasures and treasures of the world. Your writing reminds me of her.

        Sane enough to understand the insanity of life. Keenly aware of the absurdities of human behaviour and wise enough not to be disheartened by them.


          If it weren’t for that time I gave a blowjob to a spider, even I would respect me.

        • CruzSF

          But that episode still shows that you’re a giver.

    • Cocky Kurwenal

      I love Jessye’s Ariadne too -- what a perfect fit for her voice. She is so well accompanied by Levine too.

      • MontyNostry

        How big a sing is Ariadne? With the small orchestra, does it still need a voice on the Norman/Voigt/Stemme/Urmana scale, or can a lighter instrument still do it full justice? I’ve never listened to the Schwarzkopf recording, but I don’t think she ever sang it live. Janowitz did, though, didn’t she? Maybe it’s a question of amplitude rather than simply volume.


          For me, it’s the package. She is, after all, “the prima donna.” The audience should be impressed by the sheer size. Balance-wise, if she sounds like a Zerbinetta whose testicles have descended it makes little sense. There are four key points that I listen for — the character’s impact in the Prologue, the off-stage cry in the opera proper which needs to sound almost mythic, “Es Gibt ein Reich” of course, and then the final duet which will be merely endlessly banal unless the audience is continually involved with the artistry involved. Norman does it for me in a way that most of the “Vienna Ladies” don’t.


          Well shit, Kashania just said it better. Ignore me, please.

        • You sell yourself short, BAB. I could never come up with something like “a Zerbinetta whose testicles have descended”.

    • Ariadne was made for Jessye, both from a vocal and dramatic perspective.

      Vocally, the role’s tessitura was perfect for her. The few high notes were within her reach (though she lacked the shimmer and gleam of a higher soprano) and she was one of the only sopranos who commanded the low notes of the roles without sounding out of her element. She brought great amplitude of tone and breath control (just listen to 3:57 in “Es gibt ein Reich”) to her singing but also much delicate, beautiful singing (as in “Ein Schones war”).

      Dramatically, the part of a hopelessly grand diva, playing the role of a woman isolated on an island was a ridiculously good fit for Jessye. But, while she played up the comedy in the first act, she brought real pathos to the second. She didn’t make the role comical.

      Apparently, she was even better in the 84-85 season at the Met.

    • You know, Battle ruins that telecast for me. I can not stand her fake shrill Zerbinetta. That telecast should’ve had Blythe Walker as Zerbinetta. She was covering and had done one of the nymphs earlier.

      Just about anyone would have been preferable, Gruberoba, who never got a telecast of the opera while she was still owning the role. Gianna Rolandi would have been just as good.

      • ilpenedelmiocor

        Yeah, agreed — totally fake. The most real aspect is when she imperiously tries to shush the audience near the end so she can finish the last few lines of the aria.

  • callasorphan

    Jessye does indeed sing the hell out of this--I LOVE it!!

  • Bill

    Norman, despite great low notes, with her husky version, much less to my taste than renditions of
    Janowitz, della Casa, Rysanek, Benackova (or
    Schwarzkopf on records).

    • luvtennis

      For me, Jessye’s Ariadne and VLL are nonpareil. Frankly, the singers listed by Bill simply cannot compare in my opinion.

      Rysanek lacked the vocal precision to do justice to the role. Her recorded version is unreliable in pitch and dynamic.

      Janowitz is lovely and pure-toned, but the voice hardens and tightens up top and there is so little warmth of humanity in her singing.

      LDC shares many of Janowitz’s version and is warmer to boot, but the lower reaches of the role -- where so much of the music “happens” -- elude her.

      Benackova is a particular favorite of mind, but I have always found her lacking in Italian or German music. She always seemed unable to manage the consonants without breaking the line -- there is almost a gulping quality in her singing that you never hear when she is singing Czech music.

      • luvtennis


      • armerjacquino

        ‘little warmth…humanity’

        You’re kidding, right?

        • MontyNostry

          Sorry, armer, but Janowitz doesn’t touch me either — except in that video of Arabella from the late 70s.

        • armerjacquino

          I’m not talking about whether she moves you or not, Monty- just really don’t see how it’s a voice that can be accused of lacking warmth or humanity.

        • MontyNostry

          This is one of those taste issues … I first heard GJ on the Karajan Schoepfung when I was about 15, and I could hear it was beautiful (though even then I thought some of the coloratura wasn’t great), but I have always felt that her constant vocal expression is an inscrutable Mona Lisa smile.

        • parpignol

          Janowitz live in Arabella (Vienna, 1970s, opposite Waechter) was perfect, the Mona Lisa smile was just right for the role, and no Arabella ever sounded more exquisite (well, maybe Della Casa did, but I only know the recording); Ariadne: Norman live was the best I ever heard; but I thought Stemme just this season was sensational; on recording I keep going back to the Leontyne Price recording with Solti: could Ariadne be more beautiful than that?

  • Bill

    luvtennis -- some of the flaws you point out in
    the singers mentioned are so. Lisa della Casa
    (as evidenced in her 1954 Boehm DGG Salzburg Ariadne, was not as comfortable in the lowest notes though this was less evident when one saw her perform. But so often on high the voice flowed out with such radiance
    that any comparison with Norman on that scale would be superfluous

    Janowitz’s voice did harden a bit on high, particularly later in her career but not always.
    But her voice was much creamier than that of Norman, the sound brighter, the refulgent flow of sound just gorgeous, her diction close to perfection (and never

    Rysanek was an uneven performer from a vocal point of view -- and particularly earlier in her career, her
    lower notes were sort of of the fog-horn variety.
    But when her voice was under control it could have
    such excitement in the ecstatic parts that Ariadne
    has to sing as to admonish any defects.

    Of the more than 40 different Ariadne’s cast in the role whom I have experienced in the role on stage , the most absolutely beautiful I have heard (several times) was that of Benackova -- it is so that in Hollander or Fidelio, though beautifully sung, her performances lacked something of that excitement that the best Sentas or Fidelios can sum up -- but Ariadne is a bit more of a placid creature on stage -- the emotion is more in the voice than in the stage action -- and here Benackova was marvelous, pouring out gleaming note after gleaming note. I saw her thrice (all in Vienna) and the audience was absolutely rapt and enveloped in the warmth of her utterances.

    Other Ariadnes I have enjoyed include Jones (once in Vienna, replacing Janowitz, Jones was in absolute
    perfect control -- she knew it, the audience knew it and she received a rapturous and thunderous ovation at the end). I liked Gessendorf too, I liked Johanna Meier earlier in her career, I liked Norman also -- it is a deeper voice which I find lovelier in Mahler than in Strauss. I never saw Crespin but she sounds very much in control in the Chicago Lyric performance (1964). I was not as pleased with L. Price -- liked Caballe -- thought Tomowa-Sintow effective, particularly on high. Christine Brewer, among the larger voiced Ariadne’s had a splendid evening at the Met. Voigt used to be effective in the role -- probably not now. Watson was one of the best American
    Ariadnes, others were serviceable, a few were ineffective -- The last ones at the Met, Urmana and
    Stemme I felt were sort of in the middle of the pack
    I know Studer sang the role, and probably quite well, but I never saw her do it.

    We know what Reining sounded like -- have a snippet of Cebatori -- maybe nothing much of Jeritza, Lehmann, A. Konetzni. but they must have been formidable.

    Today I might favor Schwanewilms for her lovely sound, and when she gets around to doing it, Kuehmeier -- maybe the next great Ariadne.

    Strange, but Ariadne seems to be role of which Italian singers have steered clear --

    • Hmmm… I’d love to hear Crespin’s Ariadne. I think that lower sopranos like Norman (and probably Crespin) are more dramatically appropriate for Ariadne. An Ariadne whose voice soars too easily just doesn’t convey the trapped heroine the way an “earthbound” Ariadne can. They may sing with exquisite tone and style but I think the low tessitura of the role is a conscious move on Strauss’s part. The few high notes of the part, contrasting as they do with overall tessitura, illustrate the heroine’s desire to leave the island, methinks.


        Oooo, well methought, methinks. I never methought of it that way meself, but it makes mesense.

      • Bill

        Kashania -- Crespin’s Ariadne is available on
        pirated CD -- actually it is a very good Ariadne
        performance throughout -- Chicago Lyric 1964 (the Met production which Chicago borrowed for its first ever Ariadne) with Eugen Jochum conducting, Seefried, Grist, Kunz, Jean Cox as Bacchus -- there is a bit of cavern like sound -- but the opera house is large. I believe Crespin also sang Ariane in Aix and that one may be available here or there as well. What is so good about
        Crespin in the Chicago version is the wonderful
        control of voice she displays -- and of course
        she has no problem with the notes, top to bottom.

        • Thanks, Bill. I’ll look for it.

        • armerjacquino

          There are extended highlights of an Ariadne with Crespin and Mesplé on youtube, too.

          Bill- Schwanewilms is a gorgeous Ariadne. I saw her at Covent Garden and she sounded very reminiscent of Della Casa.

      • Your wish is my command Kanisha:

        • Bless you, Lindoro!

        • CL in DC

          Thanks for sharing the Crepin Ariadne, Lindoro. I still prefer Norman, but that video led me to Crespin’s “Einsam in trüben Tagen” from Lohengrin, which I found to be pretty awesome. I don’t know if ‘haunting’ is the word I’m looking for, but it is pretty spectacular.

        • ilpenedelmiocor

          I remember Crespin as being really good in Strauss (especially Rosenkavalier), but the first few notes of this clip are scary. :-)

        • MontyNostry

          ilpene …, Regine doesn’t sound too scary to me --maybe it was the after-effect of that opening picture of (?) Melchior in full Lohengrin gear. Is that Gorr being pointed out by Crespin in one of the later shots? What a combo!

        • Cocky Kurwenal

          Much as I love Crespin, this Ariadne clip is kind of horrible. It’s all very well pointing out Jessye’s intonation issues but Crespin’s here seem far worse to me.

      • It could also be that Strauss’ originally thought Ariadne to be a Contralto role, but changed his mind.

    • mrmyster

      Brewer just recorded Ariadne for Chandos, in English. We’ll see
      what you guys think. This is no place to criticize Mme Norman, so
      I wont, but I will say that her frequent less-than-in-tune singing
      pretty much robbed her of much enjoyment for me. I heard
      Janowitz sing it many years ago — 1960s — at Kennedy Center,
      with no less than a young Gruberova as Zerbinetta — it was E.G.’s
      show, Janowitz put us to sleep; exceptionally dull. Best Ariadne
      I’ve heard — on a good night, Rysanek — the perfect Strauss
      voice when on form.

      • I think Brewer’s recording could be wonderful and she does opera in English so well. The key to Norman is pre-1990. In the early 90s, she lost a lot of weight and I think this effected her support and her pitch, which became quite variable.

        • luvtennis


          Agreed about timing for Norman. The weight loss really hurt her ability to support the top.


          I can’t disagree with some of your observations, but for me, Norman sings with an acuity that works wonderfully in the role. Additionally, she is so refulgent in the middle voice where most of the role lies that the lack of true soaring top is of minimal importance for me. I would also point out that Norman, at least in the 80s, sang the isolated high notes with extraordinary presence and accuracy. Her Fidelio was likewise distinguished.


          Brewer recorded Es Gibt ein Reich a few years ago.

          It was the most perfectly sung version of the aria that I have ever heard. And it’s a favorite of mine. Price recorded a version in the late 60s that is likewise perfectly sung. Very different sounds, of course.

        • parpignol

          I was not loving Brewer’s sound in the Beethoven Missa Solemnis on Thursday evening; there was also lots else wrong with the performance, so perhaps she was just having a bad night under generally disappointing circumstances. . . from where I sat, very little vocal character or spiritual conviction. . .

      • Hippolyte

        Given that the Kennedy Center didn’t open until 1971 I’m guessing you mean the visit of the Vienna Staatsoper there in 1979?

        • mrmyster

          Yes, precisely, Hippo; thank you for being
          an aide-memoire!