Remarkably, Ramey not only sang it once, but was called back to encore the aria — an exceptionally rare moment for a bass. Even more astonishing is that the second rendition is arguably even more compelling than the first, combining absolute vocal command with heightened dramatic intensity. Moments like this are historically uncommon for bass voices and make this performance truly unforgettable.

Mr. Portafiori remembers seeing Ramey in Attila live:

For me the most exciting bass was Samuel Ramey. I saw most of his performances at NYCO and the Met. He was always thrilling vocally — and what an incredible performer. But the performance, I remember the most was when he sang Attila at NYCO. He was so exciting and charismatic on stage. He was a true grande cantante basso.