Cher Public

New waves

breaking-1Missy Mazzoli, a 36-year-old composer from Brooklyn, has created the most startling and moving new American opera in memory. This astonishing achievement—in collaboration with librettist Royce Vavrek—was part of the opening week at Opera Philadelphia, which had commissioned the work and staged its world premiere. 

The “industry audience” that was present of course expected to cheer the composer, a popular figure in New York’s new music circles. But the stunned silence when the curtain fell is not something that can be planned. Neither did the screaming ovation that followed sound like pro forma good will.

Mazzoli found a way to dramatize in music the paradoxical falling/rising of a simple girl, Bess, who from the utmost degradation and a terrible death becomes a healing spirit of love affirmed against the odds, expressing a pure impurity. The story is set on the Isle of Skye, seaside, in the 1970’s. Bess—because of her love for her husband—defies conventional lower middle class morality, a venomously repressive life-denying Christian religion to become as one with the eternal feminine, a transcendent spirit of courageous joy and affirmation. Mazzoli used a fairly simple technique, falling and rising slides which sometimes become scales that ascend and descend, to make us continually aware of the fall/rise of this great spirit.

Mazzoli proved that originality in music is not something literally never heard before but rather a combination of familiar techniques, some from the musical avant-garde of sixty years ago (what was then called musique concrete), some rooted in “serious” Western Music, some generated in the 1980’s (Minimalism). She wove them into an unexpected and rich tapestry, not heard before, not in this way and not to this effect.

Vavrek’s handling of the story, based on Lars Von Trier’s disturbing 1996 film, evoked the operatic trope of woman as redemptive force, becoming a very contemporary version of Wagner’s “The Redemption of the World through Love” idea at the end of the Ring or his Senta (like Bess a redeemer by the sea) to a Lulu-like earth spirit who embodies the shocking and disturbing sexual power of women. But unlike that unfortunate, Bess transcends what society regards as a perversion to create in death a kind of miracle.

Mazzoli is herself a performer. She began in music as an adolescent singer. She has an all-female “post-rock” band called Victoire, indeed in Breaking the Waves she uses an electric guitar as the voice of God; it had, she said “ambiguity and strangeness”. Singing was her first musical impulse in life, later refined by formidable training, and extensive experience writing “serious music.” It makes her a natural for opera. That she has a spontaneous love of music rooted in word, emotion, theater, supported by complex structures and high sophistication and a constant contact with the emotional states of characters allows her to create drama through music.

In contrast to most academically trained composers, Mazzoli understands that performers are the lifeblood of opera. They must serve but also be served by the music. With tremendous skill, Mazzoli has made the role of her heroine, Bess, an equal of the great virtuoso roles in opera.

And she found an astounding singer: Kiera Duffy, who gave one of the greatest performances I have seen in the opera house in the past 20 years, maybe more. Duffy rolled back time to become what great opera singers are supposed to be but usually aren’t now—an unforgettable embodiment of profound emotion through music. I doubt the audience at this world premiere understood that Duffy was giving an archetypal performance of tremendous authority, accomplishment, and profundity in something new. She was the great singer as both creator and servant without whom an opera can’t work.

waves-3Like the opera itself, what she did was new because it is only possible now in this precise way yet ancient because it is what the greatest composers have always yearned for—a tremendous musical performer who could live in their work, whose soul, expressed through her voice, united with the composer’s truth to attain a soaring affirmation not only of a particular narrative but of the value and magic of the form itself.

Duffy has a sweet crystalline high soprano. She is at ease over a very wide range. She was always precisely in tune and every word was clear even very high— in a Scottish accent no less! She is a superb musician, shaping phrases, allowing her voice to find the musical impulse at every second. She is also improbably brave for an operatic performer. She sang naked, was bare breasted often, and gave herself over to the sexual behavior of the character without even an instant of self-consciousness. What she did is very risky for a performer and she worked without a net, throwing herself into Bess and personifying this entire work.

Breaking the Waves, like many recent operas uses a film as its basis, not the easiest task of adaptation. Most of the operas of the past were based on plays where the narrative—however much it had to be simplified and changed to accommodate music—had already been solved for the stage. But in a film, an entire universe can be delivered directly to the viewer’s brain, encompassing events impossible to depict in a live theater.

Neither the horrifying accident that nearly kills Bess’s Norwegian husband, Jan nor her detailed sexual exploits with him and then a range of men at his request can even begin to be recreated on stage. The complex rig in the strange light of the island, the sound of waves, the dreary streets and the lives of the shadowy people who walk them can barely be hinted at on stage.

Vavrek had to find a way to tell this story on a modest sized stage in a low- budget context where much of what happens and all the locations could only be suggested in simple ways. He needed to find text that established characters directly and simply but did not reduce them to cartoons. He had to dramatize with the most simple tools—words and stage actions—without signposting or “indicating” highly specific and often strange events. He accomplished this task admirably. There was nothing silly, inapt, over-general in what he wrote. His words are well chosen for music and sound natural when sung.

The thrust of the story was maintained and never trivialized. Bess, a girl with a history of psychiatric problems (she “takes pills” for her difficulties),  falls ecstatically in love with a Norwegian rig worker named Jan. She is drawn to him by the music he and the other foreigners have brought to the island. Despite the warnings of the church elders and her mother, she marries him. She suffers intense longing when he is away. To save a friend’s life he puts himself in danger and falls, shattering his body. He is left alive but paralyzed. The kind Dr. Richardson tells Bess “sometimes it’s better to die, life shouldn’t be preserved at any cost,” but aware of the life force in Jan, Bess refuses to listen.

Jan asks her to have sex with other men and to tell him about it in detail. She is shocked at first but then agrees. Jan begins to heal slowly, apparently in response to her narratives. She begins to realize that life sometimes must be lived in fantasy, in narrative—in art. She abandons herself to all the men who approach her. She is killed. The Elders of her Church curse her soul. Her mother is shamed, her sister-in-law confronts them angrily but it is Jan—miraculously recovered—who rescues Bess’s body from their graveyard and carries her to the sea, where… well, something profoundly moving happens.

waves-2One of my teachers, Dika Newlin (Schoenberg’s youngest pupil and according to him the only genius he taught in America), felt that ultimately “music” was organized and controlled noise, that sounds preceded the tune and harmony. She’d argue that the first “music” we hear are noises comforting or frightening and that when we hear them as we age they evoke delight, childish terrors, joy, sorrow, the most complex emotions. The child hears sound—the clock, the rain against the window, the wind at a distance, the cars in the street, voices distant and close in conversations with their own shapes and cadences, someone humming, a distant radio or TV, doors slamming. A sophisticated ear will create powerful sounds with these homely noises as a basic vocabulary.

Mazzoli’s technique is founded in such sound. She harks back to the creators of electronically enhanced sound in an artistic context, and to timbres made by unusual objects. In her opera, Mazzoli uses glockenspiel, melodica, tam-tam, and car suspension spring, along with the electric guitar, standard instruments and taped sound. Mazzoli’s tinta (a musician’s fancy way of saying “color”) starts not with musical keys but with sounds that carry automatic associations, which summon concrete emotions.

Mazzoli has mentioned Janacek and Britten as influences, but Britten looms especially large. Bess’s dying calls of Jan’s name echo Peter Grimes’ keening his own name at the end of his mad scene. Mazzoli also adopts the kind of lyrical “twelve-note” technique Britten uses in Death in Venice. Her “row” is inverted, played backward, transposed and makes up most of the chords she uses. It provides melodic fragments that are molded apparently effortlessly around the words and sometimes it evolves into more sustained “tunes”.

When the Doctor reaches out to Bess, his line echoes Peter Quint’s in The Turn of the Screw when he summons Miles. That iteration of part of her row, recurring twice, and is familiar enough to pull someone who knows The Turn of the Screw out of the opera for a moment. (There’s nothing unusual in that—in Turandot, one of the other works Opera Philadelphia was offering in its opening weekend, Puccini lifts Mussorgsky’s Gopak for the Executioner, and some of Schoenberg’s Pierre Lunaire (written 1912) for the Ghost Voices (Eine blasse Wäscherin and Der kranke Mond) and that’s just for starters.)

For a listener of my generation, one technique she uses, Minimalism, is a little less convincing. Philip Glass developed this style after years of intense study and practice at the highest intellectual level and several mystical trips to Bali and India. It was in him and of him and worked well in his earlier operas, but even he has moved on. John Adams used an aspect of Minimalism in the marvelous orchestral works her wrote just before Nixon in China, such as Harmonielehre. But in his operas, I’ve been unconvinced.

I can understand the continued appeal of Minimalism to younger composers. Here it provides Mazzoli with a sure-footed shape and framework for her chords, but the impression of repetition (despite small variations) brings a kind of stasis, a slowness of movement, to a work which might have benefitted from a more volatile and eruptive impulse. That the second and third acts felt a little longer than ideal I think can be blamed on this technique.

But these are minor quibbles. Opera Philadelphia gave the opera the strong production it deserved. The director, James Darrah, found simple but effective solutions to the narrative issues and worked with the cast wonderfully. The clear lines of the set (designed by Adam Rigg), atmospheric costumes both of the period and in the mood of the piece (by Chrisi Karvonides), beautiful lighting by Pablo Santiago and remarkable projections that evoked seascapes and the eerie allure of the beach by Adam Larsen added significantly to the impact of the evening.

Steven Osgood conducted the superb cast sympathetically. Eve Gigliotti as Bess’s sister-in-law unleashed tremendous power in her rebuke of the vicious Church Elders, Patricia Schuman had compelling complexity as Bess’s mother—loving but narrow and frightened. Jon Moore, perfectly cast as Jan, has a rich baritone. Handsome enough to carry off a nude scene, he projected a powerful, sympathetic masculinity. David Portillo supplied a beautiful high tenor voice and tender sympathy as the doctor. The cast was effectively rounded out by Zachery James and Marcus DeLoach.

The evening was unforgettable for Kiera Duffy and the stunning work itself. May Mazzoli continue to write operas of this power!

Photos: Dominic M. Mercier

  • Batty Masetto

    Hooray Mrs. JC! Wish I had been able to see & hear this.

  • Krunoslav

    I really admired the WP and would point out to NYC denizens that the staging will be seen at NYU’s Skirball on January 6, 7 and 9:

    Grab tickets now!

    • Rosina Leckermaul

      Got my ticket. Can’t wait.

  • Thank you for the wonderful report.

    I love the film, which I consider one of the greatest films of the 90s. At first, the thought of an opera based on a film with no musical score seemed odd. But that was a surface reaction on my part because it’s quite apparent that the themes are quite operatic. It sounds like a triumph.

  • Ramon Figueroa

    Thanks for the thorough, learned and passionate review. Makes me feel I was there, and I can’t wait to hear the score.

  • Donna Annina

    Thanks for a brilliant review. I’ve admired Mazzoli since first hearing her Still Life With Avalanche five years ago. Her chamber opera Song from the Uproar is deeply moving and I can’t wait to see this one.

  • rhinestonecowgirl

    Sounds absolutely wonderful. Any chance of a European production? I would love to see Scottish Opera tackle this.

  • Porgy Amor

    Thank you so much, Albert. I have already shared this with a big Von Trier and opera fan. I would love to hear and see this.

  • PCally

    Finally got a chance to read this thank you so much mjc it sounds fascinating and most of the other reviews I’ve read, though nowhere near as detailed, are also very complimentary. The movie had an enormous impact on me when it came out (I still can’t imagine what Emily Watson went through to nail that role and it was her film debut!) and the opera sounds like it was incredible.

  • Gleba McHamish

    Thanks for this sensitive and thoughtful review which I think offers good insights into the work, its performance, and its place in contemporary opera. I was pretty shattered by the drama on Thursday’s performance, and was pleased, as well, to have a few beats of silence after the last notes while it all reverberated. I think librettist Royce Vavrek, whom I know only from this and Dog Days, produces an absolutely contemporary text that makes unique statements, serves real drama, and understands word shapes and how to mate his words to singing. The singers were well-cast and there wasn’t a gauche or forced moment in the evening, despite the perilously risque’ story.

  • I thank everybody on behalf of my evil twin who is now back in the attic on his hay. It is nice to be read and all of you who have commented are people I respect and I am sure my evil twin might agree were he of sound mind. He was sent some dissents by people but he shrugs those off. There will always be disagreements. Certainly, some just don’t get it but some have a genuine resistance. But having been through something similar with Mr. Claggart (before I got that rough trade to kill him) I was profoundly moved by this work. I also LOVE Lars as a film maker. He makes the story of my life constantly.

    • Luvtennis

      Mrs. JC:

      Any word of a recording????

      More importantly, do you sense that Mazzoli has more than one (or two) opera in her. If opera is to live again, then we need composers who write more than one important work. Do you think that Mazzoli is such an artist. Is her… way one that lends itself to the routine of creating a real body of work in the form? Given her age, this is an important question for me.

      • Cameron Kelsall

        There were two large cameras stationed in the parquet at last night’s performance. I have no idea if they were recording it for future commercial release or just for archival purposes, though. I hope it’s for the former — a recording of this score should exist.

  • Leontiny

    Thank you for this wonderful piece of writing. I look forward to seeing you on the comment board and miss you when you are absent. Still kicking myself for choosing NYC and Balanchine over Philadelphia and missing this. The friend I had been tossing it over with chose Philly. Here’s what they had to say about the performance:
    “Breaking the Waves was in the other hall at the Kimmel Centre -- perfect little opera house of 650 seats. I wish we had a venue like that in Toronto -- would give the COC no excuses for not mounting new work. (ok, they’d still find them).
    It was extraordinary. Music is very fine -- uses a wide array of unconventional instruments, a lot of different musical influences and makes it all work. The “voice of God” sections combines three musical ideas uniquely and perfectly. Perhaps the most interesting “new music” score I have heard. Kiera Duffy as Bess astonishing on every level. A masterpiece. With a couple of flaws. Maybe because I’m thinking about librettos a lot these days, I found it weak in parts. Where the Crucible I just saw was overwritten, I thought this was a bit underwritten. I didn’t think the intense devotion to faith and church that Bess seeks refuge in -- from her psychological/mental issues -- not clear -- was well enough established. It’s essential to setting up the profound conflict between duty and devotion to her faith and her husband. But the use of the male chorus was inspired -- representing male power in all its guises. Britten clearly an inspiration, and thought it could have established a bit more the isolation and unforgiving nature of life by the sea (at least in libretto and staging). Elements of horror of Lulu too. The final act is harrowing and the ending, although it may leave everyone off the hook a bit too easily, was profoundly moving.”
    Amazingly when I checked there were still tickets left for Oct. 1. I’m hoping to be able to be present when it’s presented in NY in early January, and thank you to Kruno for posting that.

  • Cameron Kelsall

    I saw last night’s performance (I’m reviewing it for a local news outlet) and it is absolutely astonishing. Albert’s review so beautifully communicates all of this production’s strengths — particularly Duffy’s star-is-born performance. It’s nice to see Opera Philadelphia — which can sometimes be guilty of presenting drab, safe work — shepherd something so virile and vital into existence.

    • Krunoslav

      “something so virile and vital”

      As I said I though this opera and staging was terrific, but the one thing ( besides the repeated steal from Quint’s “Miles” melisma that brought me out if its spell was the near-camp precision which which the director had the choral men report to their duties in pawing Bess in near-exact order of comeliness, muscle-tone and déshabille. Just saying.