Body and soul

Austin Opera‘s semi-staged Thaïs ravishes—and raises some rather lofty questions.

2 comments

Photo: Erich Schlegel

Is Thaïs the agent of her own salvation, or is she merely an object defined by Athanaël’s religious and sexual desires? What, in turn, can contemporary audiences learn from Massenet’s Thaïs, one of the best-known works in the nineteenth-century French operatic repertoire?

Thaïs is very much a product of its time, embodying not only the nineteenth-century opposition between religious devotion and secular desire but also the period’s fascination with exoticism. Its central conflict emerges through Athanaël, a monk determined to lead Thaïs, a courtesan in the corrupt city of Alexandria, to Christ. Yet beneath his aspiration to save her lies a secular desire of his own: the wish to possess her by separating her from other men.

The tension between religious conviction and earthly desire is also articulated through recurring musical motifs. In the Act I scene “Qui te fait si sévère?”, Thaïs teases Athanaël with a melody associated with what the 1894 review in La Liberté identifies as the “theme of the vision.” When an image of Thaïs reappears in Athanaël’s dream in Act III, the return of this motif intensifies his longing for her. The famous “Méditation,” heard after Athanaël has preached salvation to Thaïs and promised to wait for her, likewise takes on a recurring thematic function. Its reappearances as Thaïs approaches the convent of Mère Albine and, ultimately, as she dies and turns toward God in heaven suggest the contrasting trajectories of the two protagonists. Through these musical returns, the opera vividly stages the competing values and aspirations that shaped its historical moment.

Yet audiences are likely to expect more than a period piece when encountering Thaïs in a contemporary production. Presented as part of Austin Opera’s Opera Unleashed series, which expands the company’s repertoire with celebrated works new to its stage, this concert-and-projection production offered an opportunity to reconsider the opera’s relevance today. In partnership with Spoleto Festival USA, Austin Opera brought together soprano Nicole Heaston and baritone Troy Cook for their third time performing as Thaïs and Athanaël, following productions at Utah Opera in 2024 and Spoleto Festival USA in 2025.

Although audiences anticipating Thaïs’s grand entrance before a crowd of admirers or the elaborate, exotic festivities at Nicias’s house might have been disappointed by the absence of traditional operatic spectacle, the minimalist, projection-driven production by director Crystal Manich, conductor Timothy Myers, and projection designer Greg Emetaz offered a different kind of theatrical experience. Rather than simply recreating the world of the opera, the production used Thaïs’s story to raise questions about human nature and the ways we understand ourselves.

The production’s central interpretive concerns came to a head during the “Méditation.” Productions have approached it in strikingly different ways. In Stefano Poda’s 2008 production for Teatro Regio di Torino, starring Barbara Frittoli and Lado Ataneli, slow-motion movement emphasized Thaïs’s process of spiritual awakening. In the Metropolitan Opera’s 2008 production, starring Renée Fleming and Thomas Hampson, the curtain remained closed, directing the audience’s attention entirely toward the violin solo. Manich and Emetaz took another approach: Athanaël sat on the floor with his eyes closed, remaining in a meditative pose throughout the opening and closing passages of the piece. Behind him, projections showed a succession of Thaïs’s expressions, ranging from her immersion in worldly pleasure to the emptiness beneath it, and finally to her contemplation of the freedom that comes from choosing her own destiny. This sequence complicated the familiar interpretation of Thaïs as a courtesan who simply relinquishes her fame and wealth in exchange for eternal beauty. It also invited us to wonder what Athanaël might be thinking as he waits outside her house. Is his vigil a form of self-discipline, an attempt to convince himself that he is acting out of religious conviction rather than indulging his own desire to separate Thaïs from other men by making her the bride of Christ? The questions raised by this scene resonate with Myers’s description of Thaïs as “a work of remarkable emotional complexity that challenges us to reconsider the distance between who we believe ourselves to be and who we truly are.”

Photo: Erich Schlegel

Heaston made her Austin Opera debut in the role of Thaïs. Her interpretation was not a courtesan whose seductive power depended on overt displays of sensuality. Instead, she conveyed her charm through a bright, playful disposition and an ease of gesture. In her first encounter with Athanaël in Act I, during “Qui te fait si sévère?”, her voice was clear and sweet, with high notes that captured the ear effortlessly. The mirror aria, by contrast, revealed the emptiness beneath Thaïs’s pursuit of eternal beauty. From the opening phrases, Heaston shifted to a slightly darker timbre, creating a striking contrast with the preceding scene. Having returned to her private room and the solitude of her mirror, Thaïs is no longer surrounded by the many admirers who celebrate her beauty. Heaston made this transition palpable, allowing the audience to hear a woman confronting not only the transience of her physical appearance but also the void within. Her characterization ultimately suggested that Thaïs had arrived at her decision about salvation through a process of reflection and personal struggle.

Cook’s Athanaël traced a dramatic emotional arc, moving from the confident monk who boldly seeks to cleanse Thaïs of her sins and return her to Christ to a man who discovers his own physical desire for her. His final realization culminates in a desperate outburst as he rushes toward the dying Thaïs. In “Voilà donc la terrible cité!”, his response to corrupt Alexandria was less one of anger or contempt than of confidence in his own ability to bring the city to salvation. Cook’s bright, powerful vocal tone conveyed this sense of conviction. Similarly, in “Étranger, te voilà, comme tu l’avais dit,” where Athanaël again urges Thaïs toward salvation after the mirror aria, Cook avoided excessive dramatization even as Athanaël struggled to restrain his desire. This restraint made his religious mission seem all the more resolute. But once he learns that Thaïs is dying, his vocal expression changes dramatically. His cries of anguish reveal the pain of recognizing his own desire, and Cook made Athanaël’s psychological and spiritual collapse a compelling theatrical event.

As Nicias, Dominick Valdés Chenes provided welcome comic relief in a drama that grows increasingly tragic. His light yet supple voice, occasionally sharpened with the pointed delivery of a witty aside, suited the character’s playful temperament. He also displayed the vocal richness, stage presence, and natural flair of an entertainer. One particularly striking moment came at the end of the scene in which Athanaël declares that Thaïs has become the bride of Christ and leads her away. A vast image of flames appeared in the projections, and Nicias knelt before it. His posture could be read as a tribute to the golden age of secular pleasure that was now disappearing, an image of the death of the Thaïs he had known in a kind of hell, or even a foreshadowing of the contrast with Thaïs’s eventual death and ascent to heaven. The moment suggested that Nicias, despite his largely comic characterization, could raise questions that extend beyond his role as a source of amusement.

The choreography by Michael Pappalardo was particularly effective during the dance at Nicias’s party, where exoticized music accompanies the festivities. Rather than attempting to reproduce a dance from an imagined foreign culture, the choreography foregrounded its own theatrical construction. The costumes strongly evoked belly-dance attire, while the movement remained unmistakably rooted in ballet. This combination offered an unusually candid reflection of the opera’s own exoticizing aesthetic. Yuxin Liu, as La Charmeuse, also made the most of her brief appearance, delivering her short but striking melodic passage with seductive flair.

Photo: Erich Schlegel

One aspect of the production, however, was less successful. In Act III, as a storm breaks out and Athanaël rushes toward the dying Thaïs, the lighting effects were designed to amplify the projected images of waves and lightning. Several intense lights flashed in alternating patterns, but their repetition became distracting. The orchestra and Myers had already created an exceptionally dramatic musical moment, yet the lighting seemed to flatten rather than intensify its effect. At this point, I wished the production had trusted the music and allowed the audience more space to listen.

Austin Opera’s Thaïs offered an occasion to reflect on the value of selfhood and the freedom to make one’s own choices. By foregrounding the psychological complexities of its two protagonists, the production invited us to question not only Thaïs’s path to salvation but also Athanaël’s motives in seeking it for her. I look forward to seeing what other works Opera Unleashed will bring to the stage—and what further questions about our humanity they might inspire. 

Seokyoung Kim

Seokyoung Kim is an independent scholar based in Austin, Texas. She received her PhD in musicology from the University of Texas at Austin in 2026. Her research interests include opera studies, contemporary music, East Asian and Asian American music, and music criticism. Her dissertation, “Opera, Interculturality, and Asian American Voices in Huang Ruo’s M. Butterfly (2022),” examines Huang Ruo’s adaptation of Puccini’s Madama Butterfly, exploring interculturality and the representation of racial and cultural minorities in contemporary opera. Her research has been supported by grants from the American Musicological Society and the Virgil Thomson Fellowship from the Society for American Music.

Comments

Sign up for Parterre’s free newsletter.

Exclusive opera reviews, commentary, and top reads
delivered to your email weekly…ish.