Headshot of La Cieca

Cher Public

  • parpignol: huge New York success for Stemme who is clearly going to be the great Straussian and Wagnerian soprano... 11:59 PM
  • Andie Musique: I kept thinking Welzer-Moet had just read Strauss’ injunction to the orchestra If you can... 11:43 PM
  • bluecabochon: CAST: Nina Stemme, Salome Jane Henschel, Herodias Rudolf Schasching, Herod Garrett Sorenson,... 11:35 PM
  • A. Poggia Turra: They should have gotten this one: httpv://www.youtub e.com/watch?v=2bH8 q1SEHvQ 11:31 PM
  • Signor Bruschino: I was down in the orchestra and was surprised how well behaved the elderly set were this... 11:20 PM
  • Camille: Hey, mucho spasibo, Salomanda!! Already heard from husband–he said the Austrian guy who played... 10:56 PM
  • Salomanda: Quick impressions from tonight’s Salome: The orchestra sounded great but it sounded like... 10:39 PM
  • Bosah: Well, there are UK/Commonwealth singers – three hours worth of them. Just not classical singers.... 10:00 PM

siriusly

Is it just me, or does Joseph Calleja sound simply amazing? La Cieca asks: is there a better lyric tenor out there today?

69 comments

  • aristotle incarnate says:

    If anyone is interested, I’ve uploaded Calleja’s “una furtiva lagrima” to zshare, from my recording of tonight’s performance. Here’s the link.

    http://www.zshare.net/audio/5905376412c8a844/

    Enjoy!!

  • aristotle incarnate says:

    btw, it’s like monkey see monkey do with the Met audience. One idiot comes in before the aria is done and the others all jump in early too. predictable.

  • grandtier says:

    Just played Aristotle’s clip from tonight’s performances, and this is really fascinating, as Calleja’s vibrato was very much more prominent in the clip than in the house, and we were sitting in Row A. The mics are on the apron of the stage, very close to the singers, perhaps accounting for this. Also, his voice sounded much drier on Sirius than in real space. The voice is evidently one that needs space. I have heard Calleja from various places in the house, and Sirius gives little idea of the size of the voice. Trust me, it carries.

  • sean says:

    best lyric? no. best light lyric? absolutely. I don’t want to hear him sing anything heavier than rodolfo maybe ever. although I would love to hear him sing pearl fishers

  • eddiepensier says:

    I disagree, sean. To me (Ive heard him sing now Duke, Macduff, and Nemorino live), Calleja is a large lyric with some spinto qualities. I could see him singing roles like Don Jose, Pinkerton, and Ballo in the next 5-10 years (lets remember he’s only 31 as of now). He has that natural unforced ring and size to be a great lirico spinto.
    I was in the house tonight, and I loved every minute of his performance. His stage demeanor reminds me of Luciano (and no, not only because he’s a tad on the large side)

  • eddiepensier says:

    Also, I have to say having just heard it, this clip doesnt nearly do justice to the actual in house sound. So strange.

  • eddiepensier says:

    And as a final point, I think today’s 3 best tenors are
    Beczala, Calleja, and Kaufmann

  • La marquise de Merteuil says:

    The caprino or flutter happens only when support isn’t working properly – Popp also had that. Nevertheless a verry good musician with a very good instrument with a very good top – no strain W H A T S O E V E R! Bravo!

  • calaf47 says:

    Calleja was SUPERB and carried the evening on his back. The conducting and rest of the cast were secondary..but Calleja made the evening one of those “memorable” ones at the Met. BRAVO CALLEJA!!

  • ned says:

    messa di voce – it is not your imagination – she is sharp at least half the time – one can’t quite relaz when she is singing. But even apart from that she has no business singling at an A-level company – her voice is both tiny and undistinguished (if very pretty, at times).

    La Cieca is absolutely right. There is no one out there right now even in the same league as Calleja. Not as charismatic as the late lamented Villazon, but what a thrilling sound.