Change my mind about Vanessa

I know, as a musical gay boy d’un certain âge I supposed to consider this the great American opera, the equal if not superior to anything by Britten and preferable to any of that atonal garbage from the Continent.

But I really cannot find anything in Vanessa beyond a lot of campy posturing that evades any dramatic point, set to pretty but terminally bland, vaguely expressive music. To me it represents everything most objectionable in 50s high-middlebrow culture, and particularly the pre-Stonewall closety gay male subculture; better the unpretentious humanity of an Anthony Mann western than this tastefully overblown kitsch.

Comments

Sign up for Parterre’s free newsletter.

Exclusive opera reviews, commentary, and top reads
delivered to your email weekly…ish.