Cher Public

  • danpatter: What a terrific video, and what a thrilling singer she was. Thanks for posting that. 12:27 AM
  • La Cieca: But he does all this while under the influence of nothing stronger than wine. The only “happy dust” Michele knows... 12:22 AM
  • mia apulia: too bad it’s been so long since Isokaski has sung at the Met–I see she’s still quite busy (http://www.ope... 12:11 AM
  • Krunoslav: The thread topic suits this: In a review of PORGY at Spoleto USA today, James Oestreich praises the Sportin’ Life of... 11:35 PM
  • La Cieca: Then again, in early April daytime temperatures in St Perersburg average around 5 to 8 degrees Celsius, I.e., low 40s F. As I... 11:06 PM
  • Signor Bruschino: I don’t know about Graham Vick. He seems to be the type of director who doesn’t read the libretto. His... 10:22 PM
  • Alex Baker: Ugh…managed not to screw up anyone’s name this time but failed to run a NornCheck (TM)… 9:34 PM
  • Krunoslav: Stoyanova does not have Lisa on the repertory list on her website. 8:49 PM

Yesterday’s news, tomorrow

titanic_sinksWow! That Daniel J. Wakin story appearing in tomorrow’s Times has everything but the bloodhounds snappin’ at Luc Bondy‘s rear end!

There’s mystery, intrigue, pithy quotations from Peter Gelb, ungracious maundering from Franco Zeffirelli, plus of course that stuff about next season’s Tosca you previously gleaned from two weeks ago, last week, and today.  [NYT]


  • 1
    Lucky Pierre says:

    gibt mir den kopf des luc bondy!!!!!!!!!

  • 2
    Lily Bart says:

    Duelling Toscas!!!1!

    • 2.1
      sterlingkay says:

      As I said on an earlier thread Gelb seems to be absolutely LOVING this whole controversy. Having both productions in one season will generate enormous PR. I predict many Tommasinni “think” pieces.
      Franco will no doubt be sending daily, incoherent missives through the NY Times. Let the fur fly!
      Gelb is a genius….

  • 3
    Baritenor says:

    You know, I usually find myself rolling my eyes at Joshua Kosmann, but he gained major points in my books for the “weenies” comment. Because, seriously, I would love to see what happens when you NY guys get a REALLY shitty production instead of just a kind of disappointing one. And no, HOFFMANN doesn’t count as really shitty. I’m talking some crazy German deconstructionist approach, like LA’s insane Ring Cycle.

    • 3.1
      calaf47 says:

      Yes…but if the SF critic had actually SEEN it in the house instead of the “cleaned up for PBS” version, he might hold some credibility. The production was “doctored” for the cameras…and not what opening night audience saw. Another asshole critic……..

      • 3.1.1
        Jay says:

        Kosman is actually a very good critic. Much better than some NYC critics, Bernheimer and JJ excepted. If Kosman liked the HD version good for him. Should he have made perjorative remarks about Met audiences without seeing the production live? No, but he’s hardly an asshole.

          calaf47 says:

          Still…he made a blanket statement without ever seeing it live for himself. He had no right to criticize what a NYC audience saw…and the use of the term “weenies” hardly makes him a good critic.

          mrmyster says:

          Kosman is a very nice man and a reliable critic, though sometimes his conversance with opera leaves something to be desired. You have to remember one thing about Joshua, he is the product of a music education under Joseph Kerman at Berkeley, a fate i would wish for no one! Shabby little shocking professor! Joaquin Nin Culmel once told me, “I am the man who hired Kerman; biggest mistake of my life!” :)

          Alto says:

          But Kerman also was a fucking genius in his own fach.

      • 3.1.2
        CruzSF says:

        Kosman might be a nice man, but I find myself disagreeing with his assessments so often that I don’t read his reviews until after I’ve seen the performance myself.

  • 4
    Jay says:

    So whose big donor’s kid ran afowl of Elena Doria?

    Met’s Kids Sing on Without Mother Hen

    • 4.1
      Quanto Painy Fakor says:

      Shocking news! I hope Elena is getting her full benefits and a big severence pay.

      • 4.1.1
        mrmyster says:

        She has been an outstanding teacher and mentor; I vastly admire her and have to wonder what the real story is?? Maybe she was just there too long?

  • 5
    Dawson says:

    It seems Mr. Wakin is copying verbatim our Cieca’s entries.

  • 6
    Camille says:

    OT: Today’s Giacomo Puccini’s Birthday. Auguri!

  • 7
    Cassandra says:

    With every passing second the Times slides further and further into cultural irrelevance.

  • 8
    operabitch says:

    On a completely unrelated note, after seeing the new MET Hoffmann and Kathleen Kim as Olympia it struck me (he said ducking) that if nothing else they have finally found a soprano they can put opposite Barry Banks to make him look tall!

    This woman must be no more than 3 feet tall. And very bottom heavy. No matter how she sounded she looked ridiculous in that costume and if Gelb is hiring for how people look on stage it wasn’t evident in those short, fat legs and that wide ass when she bent over.

    Sorry. Happy Holidays!

    • 8.1
      Baritenor says:

      Wow, you’ve earned your name!

    • 8.2
      asdf says:

      in real life, she is a tiny, tiny woman. she has hips, yes, but she is really quite small. would you rather have some stick figure soprano who can’t sing? cause i am sure we can find plenty of those. i would take kim over a screeching skelator dessay any day.

    • 8.3
      Lucky Pierre says:

      yes, operabitch, you on the other must be a beauty to behold. like medea or one of the witches in macbeth.

      • 8.3.1
        ika1 says:

        I thought K Kim looked cute as Olympia although when watching her she reminded me of Bobby Lee from MAdTV when he does his Connie Chung impersonitations.

    • 8.4
      mrmyster says:

      Dolls often look ridiculous; that’s part of the game!

  • 9
    operabitch says:

    Since I’m not on the stage it doesn’t really matter what I look like. Why don’t people get that?

    Tiny? I was in the front row. She may be tiny from the waist up but from the waist down she looked like a cow. It was UGLY.

    • 9.1
      Anonymous Soprano says:

      Wow, you are just taking hateful and nasty to a whole new level, aren’t you?

      Well, they do say what goes around, comes around; I’d just like to be there when this little bon mot comes back to bite you in the butt…

      I love how “Gelb is all about lookism!” and then he hires someone who isn’t perfect, and it’s all, “Look at that ugly cow!”

      There have been some of the most hateful, mysogenistic comments made here lately with no moderation, that I really feel uncomfortable reading the comments anymore, for fear of what I’m going to read. Call me supersensitive, but, as a performer myself, I’d rather not hang around somewhere I’m likely to see someone calling me horrible things and making comments about my appearance.

      • 9.1.1
        No Expert says:

        She is tiny. She did look like some kind of bizarre mechanical doll in her costume (Hello! It’s Olympia!)And I thought her performance was delightful, spectacular, stunning! I wish I could have seen her in Rinaldo.

  • 10
    Lucky Pierre says:

    thank goodness you are not on stage. let’s hope you also put a bag over your head when you go outside.

    what you write here does matter though. you should choose your words carefully, you ugly whore.

  • 11
    operabitch says:

    Lucky pierre: you might want to take your own advice, dear. Don’t be so bitter.