Brilliant image, cara Cieca! They can call it “popera” if they like, but it’s pap. Amazing. But thanks, Fresno Bee, for the typo, since it inspired such a witty response from La Cieca,doyenne even of Photoshop.
You know, I think they’re pretty harmless. They don’t claim to be opera singers, like Bocelli’s machine does–they know they’re a pop boy band with classical crossover. I haven’t seen any major claims made that we should embrace them because they’ll bring the young generation into the opera house, and they’re pleasingly decorative. I think we can safely return to our usual topics, and let them make their money. If opera dies, it isn’t Il Divo that’s going to be nailing down the lid.
Well said Will! Paws off Il Divo. To criticise them in here is just plain snobbery.
They are a different genre but they still sing “music” and I’d rather see them than a jazz band or heavy metal or rap any day! (I also wouldn’t mind entertaining them individually either and they wouldn’t even need an orchestra)
“You should be able to,” Buhler says, “transmit the sentiment of the song you’re singing without them understanding the words. That’s when you’re an artist.”
What horseshit. What he is describing is a theremin concert.
Brilliant image, cara Cieca!
They can call it “popera” if they like, but it’s pap. Amazing.
But thanks, Fresno Bee, for the typo, since it inspired such a witty response from La Cieca,doyenne even of Photoshop.
Ah, Simon Cowell, the man behind Spice Girls, Teletubbies and now THIS.
There is a special room in hell for this man, mark my words.
Like true detective, La Cieca has found a way to whip it good!
Just whip it.
You know, I think they’re pretty harmless. They don’t claim to be opera singers, like Bocelli’s machine does–they know they’re a pop boy band with classical crossover. I haven’t seen any major claims made that we should embrace them because they’ll bring the young generation into the opera house, and they’re pleasingly decorative. I think we can safely return to our usual topics, and let them make their money. If opera dies, it isn’t Il Divo that’s going to be nailing down the lid.
Well said Will! Paws off Il Divo.
To criticise them in here is just plain snobbery.
They are a different genre but they still sing “music” and I’d rather see them than a jazz band or heavy metal or rap any day! (I also wouldn’t mind entertaining them individually either and they wouldn’t even need an orchestra)
“You should be able to,” Buhler says, “transmit the sentiment of the song you’re singing without them understanding the words. That’s when you’re an artist.”
What horseshit. What he is describing is a theremin concert.
Why is the gay one always stuck in the back?
Because he wants to be conveniently placed?
Q: Are we not opera singers? A: We are Il Divo!
I have heard David Miller sing Faust and Hoffmann in opera houses. Overparted but not awful.